Please rate my team (too many rookies? too little prems?)

[fatwombat]

B: Byrgoyne, Shaw, Hibberd, Lumumba, Ibbotson, Geary (Goddard, Saad)
M: Pendles, Selwood, Parker, VanBerlo, Cripps, Cockatoo, Morabito, Heeney (Vandeberg, Ellisyolman, Karkouer)
R: Goldstein, Gorringe (Nankervis)
F: Bartel, Martin, Swan, Bontempelli, Bellchambers, Salem (Clark, Lambert)

$318,900 left

Advice/Opinions appreciated, Cheers :)

[no eye deer]

Well it's definately unique! :D you need another gun in the mids, get Fyfe. Maybe one less mid pricer in the backs. Play Saad on ground and maybe Brown as backup on the bench. Gorringe? Don't think Morabito will get early games. Too many midpricers for my liking. Worth having some, but they all won't fire. Just got to pick the right ones ;), but hey, Ya never no!

[StuL]

I want to help but don't want to say 'hey take him out and put him in' so it's like my team.

So, generally. Backline way too heavy. Choose one of Byrgoyne, Shaw, Hibberd, keep Harry I reckon and choose one of Ibbot and geary. Fill the rest up with 200ks or cheaper if they get named. McI for Tigers looks the goods.

Spend that extra coin beefing up your mids. Get rid of Mora and VB and Cockatoo (unless you can put him on the bench).

Get a better ruck than Gorringe. Love Goldy.

Fwd look ok.

[arbel]

Yeah too light on in the mids at worst need 4 premos starting. Morabito don't think will get games and is way too injury prone to risk I think. Also Vandenburg and Krakeour didn't get promoted to their senior lists so need to find a replacement there.
Gorringe at R2 isn't a solid ruck choice think these need to be a set and forget thing. Also take out Nankervis and put in a cheap rookie like cox. No point in having a $123k player on the bench that won't play when you can have a $102k player doing the same and provides DPP with the FWDS.
I think only have belly if you plan on using him as DPP, hence the cox comment before. Otherwise get in a rookie. Otherwise wasting a forward spot there.

Not bad a few tweaks here and there!

[fatwombat]

Thanks for the advice guys, have rejigged it a little. How does this look?
Krakouer's place pending rookie.

B: Shaw, Hibberd, Lumumba, Ibbotson, Geary, McIntosh (Goddard, Saad)
M: Pendles, Selwood, Gray, Sloane, VanBerlo, Cripps, Cockatoo, Heeney (Miller, Ellisyolman, Krakouer)
R: Goldstein, NicNat (Cox)
F: Bartel, Martin, Swan, Bontempelli, Bellchambers, Salem (Clark, Lambert)

$19,100 Left

Advice/Opinions appreciated, Cheers :)

[arbel]

Gray needs to be in the FWDS, wasting a space for another gun mid.
If there is ever a MID (that is good, like gray) and can play on another line you pick them in that line. So gray has to be in your FWDS. I'd downgrade bartel to a rookie, sub gray fwd and pick up another gun mid