RATE THIS

Started by skdownunder, March 15, 2009, 06:28:08 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

skdownunder

backs -  goddard, p burgoyne, gilbee, drummond, j smith, raines, hill, geary, petrenko

mids - j selwood, pendlebury, judd, kerr, foley, skipworth, rich, beams

rucks - cox, leuenberger, cordy, sellar

forwards - pavlich, roughead, bradshaw, franklin, j westhoff, higgins, ziebell, sidebottom, m brown

Murphington

Backline: Wouldn't risk having Hill and J Smith as both potentially might not play (I'd get rid of Smith as he is Injury prone)

Midfield: I think Foley is injured, Kerr might get a major tag every week, Also apart from Selwood there are no real Consistant high scorers, unless your captain is Cox you may have a problem.

Rucks: Seem ok.

Forwards: Are you sure Westhoff will have a good year? (I had Gray last year, biggest mistake ever) - I also have Ziebell in my team but im considering reshuffling my team as Kangaroos play on a Sunday where-as lockout is Thursday, hopefully he wont be omitted or you'll rely on Brown and Sidebottom getting a game.

All in all - it's a decent side, if i were you i'd get rid of Geary Rich and Sidebottom and change them to 86000 rookies as some of them will get big game time this year and it'll free up alot of money for your starting team.

Hope i helped =D

skdownunder

ye thanks that helped
shame about foley, im thinking of putting adcock in for him
grimes in for smith then maybe but not really sure of who else to go for in the midfield
i agree, westhoff is a bit of a shaky option but he kicked 3 against the saints and looked better than he did last year i think

Murphington

For your bench trade...

Backline:
Geary - Suban
Midfield:
Rich - Liam Anthony
Rucks:
You could get Jacobs as with Warnock on LTI he'll most likely be elevated
Forwards: Trade Sidebottom to Taylor Walker, He is having a MASSIVE preseason and will most likely play

Tell me how much money this frees up for you? :D

mEnty

Murph, I agree with you in most instances, mainly because I don't like the players on the bench here. But IMO it can be valid to have an expensive rookie on bench, if they are going to produce gotta have them (i.e Hill is bench warming in my backs atm)