Rate This no.1 team

[shizzam]

Please rate this!
72 100 left in the bank

Backs: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Gilbee, Malceski, Hunt, Greenwood
Emg: Waters, Maguire

Mids: Swan, Vince, Ball, Dalziell, Dangerfield, Trengrove
Emg: Martin, Barlow

Rucks: Tippett, Hille
Emg: Warnock, Trengrove

Forwards: Pavlich, Harvey, Waite, J.Riewoldt, Hall, Murphy, Ziebell
Emg: Watts, Hitchcock

[korza]

Greenwood is injured
Dalziell wont play

Terrible side

5/10

[shizzam]

So because of 2 players you give it a 5/10?

[Prospector_1]

So because of 2 players you give it a 5/10?

Why ask for a rating then challenge it? You provided no framework for how you wanted it rated.

Cop the rating on the chin, and consider the advice provided. Otherwise, you risk getting no more sensible feedback, just create an argument about rating teams, which is not really what we're here for, is it?

[CFC 1979]

ok my thoughts

Greenwood hurt - yes 2-3
dalzeill won't play - 50 / 50
vince no definate starter rnd1
waite - still recovering from injury
watts - not sure when he will play

[drongo]

I think it's a pretty good team 7/10
don't listen to Korza, has nothing constructive to say.
Greenwood and Dalzeill are easy to replace if need be.
Watts will play weather its round one or round six, you have starters on the bench to cover.
it's up to you to pick a starting bench or wait for a late selection
Ruck combo is a little light on, but saying that I have the same combo.
maybe spend that 72000 to upgrade murphy harvey or waite.

[verda32]

i give u a 6, missing the 3 most important players in SC.

[drongo]

i give u a 6, missing the 3 most important players in SC.

and they are?

[Wastelander]

At a guess I'd say Ablett and Roo, no idea who the third'd be. . .