Give me some advice please. rate my team.

stormvu · March 17, 2015, 06:52:28 PM

Def: Shaw, Gibson, M johnson, Newnes, Hamling, Goddard viojo-rainbow, Saad
Mid: Ablett, Pendlebury, JP Kennedy, Priddis, Neale, Newtown, Cockatoo, Heeney Ellis-yoleman, Krakour, Lambert
Ruck: Goldstein, Maric M Cox
Fwd: Gray, Bartel, D Martin, Salem, M clack, Daniel Steele, Lonie

$94,700 left to play with rookies for Rd1
I am content with my team at the moment, I know i have no ruck cover but i am willing to take the risk unless a rookie pops up,
There is option to make some money if need be. I will wait and see what happens with Ablett to wether or not i trade him out,
I really want H taylor but have a problem now with to many Geelong players, may end up trading Cockatoo to a cheaper rookie and Newnes back to H taylor,
Cheers

prozz710 · March 17, 2015, 08:56:28 PM

Backs: Your backs are a little bit weaker to the back end. Relying on 2 of your 4 back rooks to suit up each week is a little too risky for me. I'd try and upgrade one of these. Also I'm very interested in the Gibson pickup, could be a good POD.

Mids: I'm a real big fan! Strong 4 premo's, great pickup in Neale (if he pays off) and good use of expensive rooks.

Rucks: Can't fault, very strong

Fwds: Have done well in order to keep 3 premo's in the mix and look to have selected the correct rookies.

stormvu · March 19, 2015, 04:45:41 PM

Def: Shaw, Gibson, H Taylor, H Lumumba, K Jaksch, Goddard (viojo-rainbow, Saad)
Mid: Pendlebury, N fyfe, JP Kennedy, Priddis, P dangerfield, Newtown, Cockatoo, Heeney (Ellis-yoleman, Krakour, Lambert)
Ruck: Goldstein, Z smith (M Cox)
Fwd: Gray, Bartel, D Martin, Salem, M clack, Daniel (Steele, Lonie)
$100K to play with
8/9/13 bye structure which i can work with,

Def: I shuffled around my back line to get in someone better then a rookie at D5, Shaw and Gibson are locks for me. will be looking closely between Taylor and Johnson over the weekend to get a idea of what kind of role they are playing. Lumumba is also a lock for me, more midfield time, more points, great value! loving his football again and at his best is scary. I have put Jaksch at D5 because i think he shows great value and has the potential to be a star with more opportunity at the blues. He will make quick cash and be a good opportunity to upgrade to a premium defender.

Mids: I will be watching this weekends very closely as most teams will be going in full strength, i have decide as i did last year not to have ablett. I think if he goes in with any doubt that he will be managed for the first few rounds and will drop in price and is good player to aim to trade up to in round 13 or earlier if he hits his best again. There for i traded him to Fyfe who is only getting better then allowing me to upgrade Neale to Dangerfield who will have a point to prove this year and now only being a MID could be a great POD.

Ruck: I traded out Maric for Smith but i will be watching carefully between smith and nicholls for assumes the suns number 1 ruck spot. Smith has proven before that he can maintain a decent average, if he is fully fit i think this year he take his game to another level.

Fwds: I refuse to touch, i am super happy with this line and think that i have made the right choices.

There is a few options that i have with regard to the trades i have made. I will be watching a few players this weekend and making judgement calls after that. rookies are only placeholders til round 1 until we know who will be playing,
I see 14 keepers with Smith so i am pretty happy with that also,

Cheers in advance

stormvu · March 24, 2015, 06:52:12 PM

Def: Shaw, Gibson, H Taylor, M Johnson, H Lumumba, Goddard (viojo-rainbow, Saad)
Mid:N fyfe, D Beams, Priddis, L Parker, P dangerfield, Cockatoo, Heeney, A Vandenberg (Ellis-yoleman, Krakour, Lambert)
Ruck: Goldstein, Z smith (M Cox)
Fwd: Gray, Bartel, D Martin, Salem, M clack, Daniel (Steele, Lonie)
$60k for rookies,
8/9/13 still for byes,

once rookies are set in stone i may change lumumba to Newnes, not real sure.
but i am happy with my team and will be sitting on this til the start of rd 1.

please have a rate. cheers

AntG87 · March 24, 2015, 09:54:57 PM

just a quick note from me. As a dockers supporter I can't recommend Michael Johnson.... He is too up and down in scoring and always has a chance to break down. The only defender from Freo I would take is Zac Dawson.......Jokes.....Clancee Pearce if he is in the R1 '22' which I am 80% sure he will be.

stormvu · March 25, 2015, 12:00:40 AM

Quote from: AntG87 on March 24, 2015, 09:54:57 PM
just a quick note from me. As a dockers supporter I can't recommend Michael Johnson.... He is too up and down in scoring and always has a chance to break down. The only defender from Freo I would take is Zac Dawson.......Jokes.....Clancee Pearce if he is in the R1 '22' which I am 80% sure he will be.

Yeah I can see your point with him, I really think he can be a valuable member off freo but whether he is relevant to supercoach I don't know yet. Tossing up between a few options

arbel · March 25, 2015, 12:15:27 PM

I agree that Johnson isn't a solid enough scorer to put in there so maybe look into changing him.
Also noticed you put vandenburg in but you may as well take him back out again along with krakeour as they weren't upgraded to their senior lists so need to find 2 replacements there.
No ablett or pendles, I can understand ablett with his shoulder but pendles must surely be in there. Don't really like smith as second ruck. Think that needs to be upgraded.

stormvu · March 25, 2015, 07:47:54 PM

Quote from: arbel on March 25, 2015, 12:15:27 PM
I agree that Johnson isn't a solid enough scorer to put in there so maybe look into changing him.
Also noticed you put vandenburg in but you may as well take him back out again along with krakeour as they weren't upgraded to their senior lists so need to find 2 replacements there.
No ablett or pendles, I can understand ablett with his shoulder but pendles must surely be in there. Don't really like smith as second ruck. Think that needs to be upgraded.

Already swapped him out for Newnes. Rookies will all change at round 1,
The reason why I haven't taken pendles is because at the start of the year there is going to be so much pressure oon him to perform well. He is on my upgrade list and after Rd 6 I think he would of dropped in money and greenwood will be back and hopefully some younger players have stepped by then.