Think I am close to final team lineup... Thoughts? Rating?

Started by ArthurDent, March 14, 2015, 11:53:40 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

ArthurDent



Seem to have a fair bit of cash left. ($100k)

I have been considering replacing Gawn and am wondering about taking a huge punt and replacing him with Jamar.....


Alka

Curious why Gray in mids?

Salem for me is too expensive an F7. Even if his last NAB outing was ridiculous, I don't him scoring that in season. I'd look at a Lambert/Karnezis.

That downgrade could open up a lot of options for Gawn. Personally neither Melbourne ruck-man does anything for me.

Otherwise, very solid forwards. Good defenders. Haven't seen Hodge in too many teams but could pay off with very few real premos around.

7/10 for me.

pommyadam

Quote from: Alka on March 16, 2015, 11:16:55 AM
Curious why Gray in mids?
That downgrade could open up a lot of options for Gawn. Personally neither Melbourne ruck-man does anything for me.

I would say that Gray is a "what to do with this cash" and decided to at least get a fwd keeper, rather than a midfield stepping stone

Also like the Gawn pick, think a Dee ruckman will score well if they roll out with one of them (either Jamar or Gawn)
not too convinced of your lower Def picks - neither Whitecross or ZJones have played yet this NAB, and 260k is a LOT to leave on the bench (possibly give it to NJ Brown instead, at least he's getting regular games, even if they are 50s)

Barra13

Pretty much what has been said above. On the Gawn side of things, Jamar is easily the #1 ruck, I don't think Gawn will play every game this year and will be swapped with Pederson at times. In my eyes I see Pederson ahead of Gawn be cause he competes harder. But nonetheless, there are better options.

Also not a big fan of Fyfe, sure he's a gun, but could hurt with shoulder injuries as it is quite common for him.