Who would you rather?

Started by YoungGun, March 02, 2015, 02:23:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

YoungGun

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on March 02, 2015, 03:49:07 PM
Team is very similar to mine :)

Get rid of Minson. There's one spot you can use the cash. Turn Rainbow into Brown for better coverage. Biggs to cheaper rookie and Wells into Premo? Even Ibbo/Geary to WhiteX if not enough cash to get that premo

There are always plenty of options. Just go with your gut and do what you feel is right :)

Thanks RD, have to keep Biggs cause he is a close friend of mine haha but what you suggest is a good idea.

Why dont you like Minson? apparently he was leading Hitouts to Advantage in 2013 (big stat considering rule changes) and struggled through a back complaint all last year affecting his output. Most of all for me because I dont have ruck cover, he always plays

RaisyDaisy

There have been times where Big Wilbur has been talked about being dropped

No doubt he is durable and a solider, but I just personally think there are better options

Seeing as you're close friends with Biggs perhaps you can enlighten us all? Does he think he is best 22? Will he play a lot this year? Start rd1?

YoungGun

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on March 02, 2015, 03:55:55 PM
There have been times where Big Wilbur has been talked about being dropped

No doubt he is durable and a solider, but I just personally think there are better options

Seeing as you're close friends with Biggs perhaps you can enlighten us all? Does he think he is best 22? Will he play a lot this year? Start rd1?

I think he is defs in there best 22, had a small training knock and wasn't risked in the first NAB match. From what I know he wasnt played because they want him playing round 1. I expect him to line up round 1 and expected him to play plenty of games, skills are very good and thats what the dogs need off HB. Especially, dont know if anyone saw but after Murphy went off in the NAB game there rebounding from defensive 50 was terrible. Shane should have a role here

LordSneeze

How about taking all 4. Lol.

YoungGun

You're an ideas man hahaha if i found another 50k i could turn fisher into kelly and have enough for nvb lol

YoungGun

Quote from: LordSneeze on March 02, 2015, 05:19:28 PM
How about taking all 4. Lol.

made me think a little harder haha couldnt choose between Fisher and Kelly so ive decided to get both.  Turned wells into NVB and upgraded ibbo to kelly starting with 5 premo defenders + geary. Feels good