NAB Cup Player Watch and Rookie Watch: Discussion Thread

[eaglesman]

Didn't Brayshaw cop a heavy knock to the head in a recent intra club game?

It wasn't too heavy a knock but in saying that, it was from the human wrecking ball in Jack Viney.

The head knock he sustained a couple of weeks ago has nothing to do with him not being named against Freo though.

Didn't he cop another in training only a few days ago too?

I think he may have had another minor head knock but he trained fully today and took part in the match simulation.

He hasn't been named against Freo because he is not in the frame for a round 1 debut.

We'll see him at some stage this year though I'm sure.

Thoughts on vandenberg then ?

[ben_020285]

Didn't Brayshaw cop a heavy knock to the head in a recent intra club game?

It wasn't too heavy a knock but in saying that, it was from the human wrecking ball in Jack Viney.

The head knock he sustained a couple of weeks ago has nothing to do with him not being named against Freo though.

Didn't he cop another in training only a few days ago too?

I think he may have had another minor head knock but he trained fully today and took part in the match simulation.

He hasn't been named against Freo because he is not in the frame for a round 1 debut.

We'll see him at some stage this year though I'm sure.

Thoughts on vandenberg then ?

He didn't play in our practice match the other week but it's good to see that he has been named to play in the squad to play Freo as he has been training strongly.

If he is named in the final side to play Freo and he plays well in that game and the other NAB matches then it will give him a good chance to be upgraded to the senior list and possibly play round 1.

[Hawker_08]

Looking forward to this game. It will give us a good insight into quite a few rookies and mid pricers. Here is my list:
Walters
C Pearce
Barlow
Hogan
Salem
Lumumba
Newton
Vandenberg
Garlett
Stretch

[kilbluff1985]

could anyone please tell me the percentage of ownership of both Brodie and Devon Smith please

[Woppa15]

could anyone please tell me the percentage of ownership of both Brodie and Devon Smith please

Brodie Smith 12.70%

Devon Smith 1.29%

[frenzy]

Looking forward to this game. It will give us a good insight into quite a few rookies and mid pricers. Here is my list:
Walters.....OK, pass mark
C Pearce.....OK pass mark to very serviceable close to BOG
Barlow..... rolled ankle?, but I don't know how he's on your list? mid pricer?
Hogan...... lock him in
Salem...... useless still chuck him out
Lumumba...OK pass mark...maybe back in peoples calculations
Newton....... good but subbed at half time?
Vandenberg....green vested on at half time then good
Garlett..........nothing in 1st half, done something in the 2nd
Stretch........DNP

watch the critics come flying, but thats how I saw it.

[sammy123]

Looking forward to this game. It will give us a good insight into quite a few rookies and mid pricers. Here is my list:
Walters.....OK, pass mark
C Pearce.....OK pass mark to very serviceable close to BOG
Barlow..... rolled ankle?, but I don't know how he's on your list? mid pricer?
Hogan...... lock him in
Salem...... useless still chuck him out
Lumumba...OK pass mark...maybe back in peoples calculations
Newton....... good but subbed at half time?
Vandenberg....green vested on at half time then good
Garlett..........nothing in 1st half, done something in the 2nd
Stretch........DNP

watch the critics come flying, but thats how I saw it.

Hogan LOCK

Vandenberg went bang if he played a full game would of scored big nearly a lock if he keeps it up in the next game

[eaglesman]

Looking forward to this game. It will give us a good insight into quite a few rookies and mid pricers. Here is my list:
Walters.....OK, pass mark
C Pearce.....OK pass mark to very serviceable close to BOG
Barlow..... rolled ankle?, but I don't know how he's on your list? mid pricer?
Hogan...... lock him in
Salem...... useless still chuck him out
Lumumba...OK pass mark...maybe back in peoples calculations
Newton....... good but subbed at half time?
Vandenberg....green vested on at half time then good
Garlett..........nothing in 1st half, done something in the 2nd
Stretch........DNP

watch the critics come flying, but thats how I saw it.

Largely agree ... Would like another look at salem however
Lumumba at his price didn't convince me just yet

[kilbluff1985]

yeah love the look of Vandeberg

[kilbluff1985]

Sgt. Supercoach ‏@SgtSupercoach  1m1 minute ago
Interesting #supercoach scores from that game. Vandenberg with the 69 in a half of footy and Newton with 59 who got subbed off at half time.

[Money Shot]

Don't give up on my man Salem just yet :'(
VandenBerg and Hogan are locks ATM.

[Grazz]

Don't give up on my man Salem just yet :'(
VandenBerg and Hogan are locks ATM.

Newton looked ok before being subbed to.

[AaronKirk]

Clancee looked good for a 270k defender. Into my calculations.

[Grazz]

Clancee looked good for a 270k defender. Into my calculations.

Shhhhh delete that haha.  ;)

[Money Shot]

Don't give up on my man Salem just yet :'(
VandenBerg and Hogan are locks ATM.

Newton looked ok before being subbed to.

He did!
Wouldn't be putting him in your sides just yet though!