NAB Cup Player Watch and Rookie Watch: Discussion Thread

[RaisyDaisy]

152 SC points today from 25 disposals for Geary.

Savage had 20 touches at 80% efficiency off half back. 102 SC

Rich 97 SC. Played a lot across half back. Had more rebound 50's than any other Lion.

I would put a pen through Membrey. Was pretty ordinary. Could well be picked for round one but he didn't do enough IMO.

I said in another thread a few days ago that I wouldn't touch Membrey. NRoo is the only KPP at St Kilda, don't touch anyone else

Geary has some really big scores in his history.

If I was going to take a risk on a mid price defender he would most likely be the one. Ibbo, Yeo etc just don't have the ceiling he has

[Nige]

^ Yep.



Full time ‪#‎NABChallege‬ Macrae 130, Wallis 120, T Boyd 98, Bontempelli 91, Lambert 85, Lennon 73 and Knights 69.

SuperCoach Points via @FantasyFreako

[RaisyDaisy]

Hmmm some really good signs out of the Bris/STK game

Geary as a mid pricer - let's see how he goes over the next 2 matches

Adcock tonned up, and besides last year his previous years saw averages around 90

Fisher, well I've been on him since last year, but I guess more will follow now :(

Newnes looking like a breakout contender

Leuey doesn't look like a good option, especially considering Martin didn't even play (Martin looks absolutely ripped and will clearly be the number 1 ruck)

Lonie scored well considering he started as sub

Savage and Rich should interest people too, but not me personally

[Nige]

Geary as a mid pricer - let's see how he goes over the next 2 matches

Fisher, well I've been on him since last year, but I guess more will follow now :(

Lonie scored well considering he started as sub

Yep, yep and yep!

Squeezing Geary in somehow could be a great option if a Zak Jones type doesn't pop up.

Happy with that return from Fisher, hopefully it continues. Hoping others will continue to be scared off though.

I really wanna pick Lonie and he's given a good reason to do so.

[RaisyDaisy]

SUPERCOACH SCORES

130 Jack Macrae

120 Mitch Wallis

104 Shaun Hampson

104 Liam Picken

100 Luke Dahlhaus

98 Tom Boyd

95 Matt Arnot

94 Matthew Boyd

91 Marcus Bontempelli

89 Lin Jong

86 Koby Stevens

85 Anthony Miles

85 Kane Lambert

84 Will Minson

82 Jack Redpath

77 Jake Stringer

76 Easton Wood

73 Ben Lennon

72 Lachie Hunter

69 Chris Knights

69 Jake Batchelor

69 Taylor Hunt

67 Mitch Honeychurch

66 Sam Lloyd

64 Ricky Petterd

61 Tory Dickson

61 Matt McDonough

61 Robert Murphy

57 Michael Talia

57 Joel Hamling

55 Jordan Roughead

55 Dylan Grimes

54 Todd Elton

53 Jason Johannisen

52 Steven Morris

51 Jason Castagna

49 Shaun Grigg

47 Jarrad Grant

46 Nick Vlastuin

45 Nathan Drummond

45 Ty Vickery

42 Nathan Gordon

42 Reece McKenzie

38 Jayden Short

35 Liam McBean

34 Dan Butler

30 Nathan Hrovat

25 Dale Morris

24 Josh Prudden

24 Tom Liberatore

11 Connor Menadue

[Blues Blues Blues]

Anyone know why Biggs didn't play?

[Nige]

73 from Beatle is pretty promising.

[honza]

Shaun Hampson is an interesting one. Read before that he's one of the best tap to advantage rucks in the comp.

[RaisyDaisy]

Shaun Hampson is an interesting one. Read before that he's one of the best tap to advantage rucks in the comp.

Was very good for me last year too, but wont play when Maric is in

[LordSneeze]

Hmmm some really good signs out of the Bris/STK game

Geary as a mid pricer - let's see how he goes over the next 2 matches

Adcock tonned up, and besides last year his previous years saw averages around 90

Fisher, well I've been on him since last year, but I guess more will follow now :(

Newnes looking like a breakout contender

Leuey doesn't look like a good option, especially considering Martin didn't even play (Martin looks absolutely ripped and will clearly be the number 1 ruck)

Lonie scored well considering he started as sub

Savage and Rich should interest people too, but not me personally

Geary always does well in preseason, but has never delivered in the real season. Is a risky pick, but then so are Yeo, Seedsman, Ibbotson.
Ive been on Adcock for a while as a potentially good option, but im still not convinced. I want to see more and track his TOG over the preseason.
With Fisher, Newnes, Geary and Goodard all in the backline. Can you pick more than 2?
Leuy was never in my team, too injury prone, no idea how he will go with the new rules and Martin playing.
Lonie is still unlikely to play, but if for some reason he does he is a massive chance to be sub or get dropped after 2-3 matches.
No to Savage for me, Rich is an option, but really unlikely for me to pick.

[Nige]

Confirmed ACL for Libba.  :-\

First Ezy and now Libba, very nervous about today's games.

[The_Captain]

Confirmed ACL for Libba.  :-\

First Ezy and now Libba, very nervous about today's games.

What is lyf now... # pondering

[sammy123]

Hooe no one gets injured today

[honza]

Been a real handy pre season so far, have learned jack shower about Caleb Daniel, McKenzie, Maynard, Goddard, won't know shower about Brayshaw and know not to pick Libba.

[Mat0369]

Enter Liam Picken