Unique Defenders Poll

[diamw90]

Just a poll that can help all of us. any opinions just state below, if you think i should add someone let me know.

[aussied]

with blicavs becoming a defender, i see mackie playing down the wing abit more, but also it is said the kelly will be getting more mid time with bartel

[My Chumps]

Currently have Birch but not sure how much of a POD he'll be.

[Bully]

There needs to be Houli in the mix, a 90 average isn't out of the question.

[diamw90]

I see what you mean about houli, I'll add him as soon as I get home. Keep the votes coming in guys

[diamw90]

Houli Added

[nrich102]

Take a look here mate.

[diamw90]

Take a look here mate.

cheers nrich, this is more-so about the blokes who we think "yes... nah... maybe" newnes, shaw, hibberd etc are more locks to people. ive made this poll more about the guys who we are scared to put in because we really dont have many opinions on them.

[AaronKirk]

Currently have Birch but not sure how much of a POD he'll be.

Birchall for me is a Lock if he is right for round one.

[diamw90]

Currently have Birch but not sure how much of a POD he'll be.

Birchall for me is a Lock if he is right for round one.

Leaning towards that aswell... not sold on hurn, he kinda burnt me last year (side traded to DSwallow) but seems to struggle to find points consistently and gets them in bunches.

[GoLions]

Currently have Birch but not sure how much of a POD he'll be.

Birchall for me is a Lock if he is right for round one.

Leaning towards that aswell... not sold on hurn, he kinda burnt me last year (side traded to DSwallow) but seems to struggle to find points consistently and gets them in bunches.

Unsubbed he's gone 90+ the last 3 years. Definitely has the scoring capability, just whether his body holds up or not.

[LordSneeze]

Here are the % in teams

Corey Enright - 1.59%
James Kelly - 1.53%
Robert Murphy - 1.61%
Josh Gibson - 2.19%
Grant Birchall - 6.67%
Shannon Hurn - 5.59%
Sam Fisher - 3.27%
Luke Hodge - 17.9%
Andrew Mackie - 1.13%
Bachar Houli - 1.29%

Take out the 4 in bold and add in the following and you would have a bit of a better Unique defender poll.
Howe 0.80%
Duffield 1.61%
Huley 0.88%
Dunn 0.62%

Really surprised no-one has picked Houli and that he is in so few teams. Has missed 2 games in 4 years and has had averages of 83,83,89,91.

[H1bb3i2d]

Here are the % in teams

Corey Enright - 1.59%
James Kelly - 1.53%
Robert Murphy - 1.61%
Josh Gibson - 2.19%
Grant Birchall - 6.67%
Shannon Hurn - 5.59%
Sam Fisher - 3.27%
Luke Hodge - 17.9%
Andrew Mackie - 1.13%
Bachar Houli - 1.29%

Take out the 4 in bold and add in the following and you would have a bit of a better Unique defender poll.
Howe 0.80%
Duffield 1.61%
Hurley 0.88%
Dunn 0.62%

Really surprised no-one has picked Houli and that he is in so few teams. Has missed 2 games in 4 years and has had averages of 83,83,89,91.

If I wanted an average of 80-85, I'd save the money and go Seedsman or Yeo perhaps. Otherwise, I'd fork out just the slightest bit more for a 90+ scorer.

Hurley would be in my team if not for his bye :(

[brudski]

Anyone thinking kelly over hurn? I had hurn last year and burnt me pretty bad. Kelly has been good in previous years and with talk of more mid time could be worth a look

[H1bb3i2d]

Anyone thinking kelly over hurn? I had hurn last year and burnt me pretty bad. Kelly has been good in previous years and with talk of more mid time could be worth a look

I really rate Kelly as a top choice this year. However, there are so many nice round 11 bye defenders, I plan on picking one up as an early upgrade (depending on who's travelling well) and one during the byes, so I won't start with any.

Kelly, Simpson, Birchall, Smith, Jaensch etc.