X vs Y

[Money]

Priddis or J Redden?

I'm a big Redden fan but I'll have to give the points to Priddis here!

[natedoggy2233]

Newton or Jono O' Rouke

[TomK]

Newton mate

[Money]

Ablett, Ellis-Yomen, Mumford

vs

Rockliff, Rich, Bellchambers

[Tonche]

Sidebottom vs. Beams

Edit: I like the 2nd combo above. Too much doubt on Ablett and Ellis-Yolmen and Mummy is too injury prone.

[Money]

Sidebottom vs. Beams

Edit: I like the 2nd combo above. Too much doubt on Ablett and Ellis-Yolmen and Mummy is too injury prone.

I'd have to go Sidebottom! Think they'll both avereage around 110-115 but Sidey will just edge him out!

[Tonche]

Thanks, got a draft tomorrow and have the dreaded pick 3. Think I'm going to pick one of these two,

[Ricochet]

Thanks, got a draft tomorrow and have the dreaded pick 3. Think I'm going to pick one of these two,

I'd go DMartin or KSimpson with pick 3

[Rusty00]

Swan v Bennell?

Haven't watched the Collingwood game from last night as yet, comments on this forum were that he was average yet he still scored 96. Bennell slightly cheaper and current signs are he is ready to break out.

[pommyadam]

imo Swan's lost his ability to really go big (like captaincy big), but I'd still back him to be top 8 fwd come year end (over 95)
don't think Bennell is that good yet, remembering that Gaj and JOM still need to return to the Suns lineup
Bennell for the early rounds, but I'd back Swan in over the season

NAB averages:
Bennell = 95 from 74% TOG
Swan = 76 from 67% TOG

[natedoggy2233]

J Anderson and leave dusty in the fwds or move dusty to mids and get honeychurch

[Money]

J Anderson and leave dusty in the fwds or move dusty to mids and get honeychurch

If Anderson is named R1 then that option! i like Honeychurch but I think you'd be better off with Dusty in the forwards!



Ablett, Rich, Bellchambers

vs

Lewis, Vandenberg, Maric

[Mr.Craig]

Ablett, Rich, Bellchambers

vs

Lewis, Vandenberg, Maric

I think you should be picking Vandenberg regardless, presuming he's there Round 1.

Those two combos seem fairly well matched.

[Money]

Ablett, Rich, Bellchambers

vs

Lewis, Vandenberg, Maric

I think you should be picking Vandenberg regardless, presuming he's there Round 1.

Those two combos seem fairly well matched.

Should've clarified Vandeberg is just being moved from the bench to the field! He's in both options though!

[Ricochet]

J Anderson and leave dusty in the fwds or move dusty to mids and get honeychurch

If Anderson is named R1 then that option! i like Honeychurch but I think you'd be better off with Dusty in the forwards!



Ablett, Rich, Bellchambers

vs

Lewis, Vandenberg, Maric

Lewis Vandenberg Maric

Not a fan of Rich in AF and Belly probably won't be there round 1