X vs Y

[Ricochet]

Bit like over on the SC board.


Been thinking about this one this today:

Hannebery + Fwd Rookie (Karnezis/Krakouer/Clark/etc)
vs
Deledio + Mid Rookie (Dumont/Acres/Drummond/etc)

[Money]

Oh that's a tough one! I'd go Delidio and a mid rookie! Just because I think Lids and Hannas will average around the same and then a mid rookie has a better chance at scoring than a forward (well usually)

[Rusty00]

Yeah Deledio and mid rookie for me.

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Deledio + mid rookie, although Martin > Deledio.

[Ricochet]

Cheers fellas. If you have any of you're own chuck them up

[Rusty00]

Hibberd (D2) + Newton (M6) + Goldstein (R2)
or
Seedsman (D4) + Ward/Dangerfield (M5) + Bellchambers (R2)

Option 1 has 2 premiums compared to 1 in Option 2, but really trying to get a premium/fallen premium in at M5?

[Kellogscrunchynut]

I'd go option 2

[nrich102]

Hibberd (D2) + Newton (M6) + Goldstein (R2)
or
Seedsman (D4) + Ward/Dangerfield (M5) + Bellchambers (R2)

Option 1 has 2 premiums compared to 1 in Option 2, but really trying to get a premium/fallen premium in at M5?

Option 1 imo.

[Ricochet]

Hibberd (D2) + Newton (M6) + Goldstein (R2)
or
Seedsman (D4) + Ward/Dangerfield (M5) + Bellchambers (R2)

Option 1 has 2 premiums compared to 1 in Option 2, but really trying to get a premium/fallen premium in at M5?

Option 1 imo.

Yeh option 1 for me too. Not sure the premo in option 2 will be top 10 either.

[Barra13]

Ibbotson, Vlastuin or Whitecross?

[Football Factory]

Ibbotson, Vlastuin or Whitecross?

Ibbotson: Good value if fit and firing for round 1 ?
Vlastuin: Not consistent enough yet imo
Whitecross: Great value if he's named round 1 but i feel there is a vest danger early on.

Im leaning towards Ibbotson, depends on what you're after i guess D4,5,6 ?


I have a couple if that's alright  ;D

Deledio  vs  Dusty Martin

and

Bellchambers  vs  Jack Martin

[Rusty00]

I have a couple if that's alright  ;D

Deledio  vs  Dusty Martin

and

Bellchambers  vs  Jack Martin

Dusty and Bellcho for me.

Not sure why but I see Dusty as a safer bet this year than Lids. I think the other 2 will average around the same so have picked Bellcho for his ruck coverage ability

[Football Factory]

I have a couple if that's alright  ;D

Deledio  vs  Dusty Martin

and

Bellchambers  vs  Jack Martin

Dusty and Bellcho for me.

Not sure why but I see Dusty as a safer bet this year than Lids. I think the other 2 will average around the same so have picked Bellcho for his ruck coverage ability

Cheers Rusty  :)

Yeah got Belcho at the moment like you say ruck cover is good and he's not a green vest candidate, red yeah but not green.

Ive got Lids at the moment only because he averged 115 in his last 5 games opposed to Martins 90.

[Barra13]

Ibbotson, Vlastuin or Whitecross?

Ibbotson: Good value if fit and firing for round 1 ?
Vlastuin: Not consistent enough yet imo
Whitecross: Great value if he's named round 1 but i feel there is a vest danger early on.

Im leaning towards Ibbotson, depends on what you're after i guess D4,5,6 ?


I have a couple if that's alright  ;D

Deledio  vs  Dusty Martin

and

Bellchambers  vs  Jack Martin

It is for D5. Backline reads: B.smith, J.Newnes, H.Lumumba, P.Seedsman, ????, B.Smedts (Z.Jones, J.Goddard)

Martin > Deledio - Lids is also managing achilles soreness at the moment so keep an eye on that too.
Martin > Bellchambers - Although, depends if you're chasing that ruck link for backup?

[Mr.Craig]

Ben Lennon vs Christian Salem vs Jesse Hogan.