Hogan and Salem

[Mat0369]

Was Garlett at HF today? heard he kicked 1 or 2

He kicked 4

Garlett was a handy crumber getting to the fall of the ball and snapping three of his four goals in opportunistic fashion.

[ben_020285]

I think Garlett will be a great acquisition for the Dees this year and hopefully he'll kick around about 40 goals but I don't think he's fantasy relevant playing the small forward role.

[RaisyDaisy]

I think Garlett will be a great acquisition for the Dees this year and hopefully he'll kick around about 40 goals but I don't think he's fantasy relevant playing the small forward role.

This

Will most likely average 70ish, and at 250k not worth it

[PICCOLLO]

Garlett in a side that prefers not to go fwd. no thanks.

Good signs for Salem. A lock if he can play some quality NAB footy, particularly as he'll get some HB/mid time.

[Money Shot]

Hogan: lock
Salem: if you have the money at F5 get on
Garlett: no

[Hoggyz_a_legend]

Hogan: lock
Salem: if you have the money at F5 get on
Garlett: no

This. I've managed to get Salem, Clark and Hogan F5-7 and am much happier only needing to field one of Clark and Hogan.

[RaisyDaisy]

This. I've managed to get Salem, Clark and Hogan F5-7 and am much happier only needing to field one of Clark and Hogan.

Same here, and having Krakouer at F8 and Lambert at M9 to swing the two

[Mat0369]

Hogan: lock
Salem: if you have the money at F5 get on
Garlett: no

It is all about the early season average with Jeffy. If you can get a 90 average early in the season before his confidence drops (which he has done before) then you get a pretty good stepping stone.


The other two I have had locked in for the last couple of weeks

[RaisyDaisy]

Granted his first 6-8 weeks of 2013 were excellent, but other than that he has never been SC relevant, so for me the reward just doesn't outweigh the risk

[Jukes]

Based Hogan GOD

[Grufflez]

Hogan: lock
Salem: if you have the money at F5 get on
Garlett: no

It is all about the early season average with Jeffy. If you can get a 90 average early in the season before his confidence drops (which he has done before) then you get a pretty good stepping stone.


The other two I have had locked in for the last couple of weeks

This is true, you wouldn't be picking him as a keeper.
90 ave over 6-7 rounds might be a big ask though and at 75 or so might increase a bit too slow.

[muggle25]

Wonder how Ben Newton went.  The article mentioned pretty much all of the newcomers to the club - except Newton!

[RaisyDaisy]

Wonder how Ben Newton went.  The article mentioned pretty much all of the newcomers to the club - except Newton!

Check out the Melbourne discussion board here - he didn't do much at all  :-\

[eaglesman]

Hating this thread

[redfield]

Hogan is most definitely a lock at this stage. You'd be mad to leave him out. He will play every game if fit and the absolute worst I can see him averaging is 60. In most other teams that would be 75.