Who is the one pick you're really questioning?

[Ringo]

should say all 30 picks haha

seriously though questioning Lumumba at D3 as a risk.

[fidou]

What do people think of Zeiball, Koladashnij(GC), and Yeo.

[nrich102]

What do people think of Zeiball, Koladashnij(GC), and Yeo.

Zeiball - Nope. Can't pick him with the other forwards around.
Kkolo - nope. 2nd year blues.
Yeo - Maybe. Think he could go into the midfield and has the potential to play through the middle. Watch through the nab.

[Adamant]

That would have to be Heath Shaw, for obvious reasons.

[AaronKirk]

Brad Crouch

Has a stack of ability and won't cop attention with it going to Danger and Sloane. But I'm unsure with his lack of experience and issues with durability with him to be an M5.

Another couple of decent performances in the NAB challenge and he will be in my side. He was excellent in the 3 quarters he played yesterday.

[Rusty00]

Brad Crouch

Has a stack of ability and won't cop attention with it going to Danger and Sloane. But I'm unsure with his lack of experience and issues with durability with him to be an M5.

Another couple of decent performances in the NAB challenge and he will be in my side. He was excellent in the 3 quarters he played yesterday.

I've had him at M5 since my first draft. I was wavering a bit, but yesterday has given me back some confidence I may be able to keep him there.

Almost hope that his game time is limited the next couple of weeks so more people don't jump on him :P

[The_Captain]

Brad Crouch

Has a stack of ability and won't cop attention with it going to Danger and Sloane. But I'm unsure with his lack of experience and issues with durability with him to be an M5.

Another couple of decent performances in the NAB challenge and he will be in my side. He was excellent in the 3 quarters he played yesterday.

Hrmmmmm. Says 94% game time on afl site?

[hawkboy80]

Labamba at D3, has been in & out of my team, just can't decide

[SydneyRox]

Cant say I am happy with Nic Nat ATM

[Barra13]

Personally I don't see all the hype behind Nic Nat. He has some shocking games, last year at the Derby he didn't even take one mark. He just doesn't get involved enough around the ground for AF/DT in my eyes.

[Rusty00]

Personally I don't see all the hype behind Nic Nat. He has some shocking games, last year at the Derby he didn't even take one mark. He just doesn't get involved enough around the ground for AF/DT in my eyes.

Yeah I haven't really considered him for DT/AF as he is more suited to the SC scoring system.

Having said that, my R2 selection is nowhere near finalised yet :-\

[Ricochet]

Starting to question Tom Mitchell. Really didn't get much opportunity on the ball on the wkend, so hopefully he does in the next NAB match

[Alka]

Personally I don't see all the hype behind Nic Nat. He has some shocking games, last year at the Derby he didn't even take one mark. He just doesn't get involved enough around the ground for AF/DT in my eyes.

He's "solo rucking", that's got people excited. Some players just aren't DT friendly scorers, and while Nic Nat has talent, it just doesn't translate into DT scoring. I agree, stay away.

[SydneyRox]

Starting to question Tom Mitchell. Really didn't get much opportunity on the ball on the wkend, so hopefully he does in the next NAB match

You wont want to read this one then.

http://coachespanel.com.au/how-to-scratch-a-titch/

Some really good thoughts on why not to pick him, I cant argue with anything, but am still holding him in my team

[Ricochet]

Starting to question Tom Mitchell. Really didn't get much opportunity on the ball on the wkend, so hopefully he does in the next NAB match

You wont want to read this one then.

http://coachespanel.com.au/how-to-scratch-a-titch/

Some really good thoughts on why not to pick him, I cant argue with anything, but am still holding him in my team

Yeh saw that one, don't agree with it though. TMitchell is top 7 inside mids for you boys. Not sure why he didn't get that much time on the ball on the weekend but I'm certain it was something other than him not being in that top group of mids.