Taylor Adams

[Fid]

What are your thoughts on this guy?

Was the second best clearance behind Callan Ward when @ the Giants and averaged 75 and 76 points whilst there.

Last year played just the 12 games with Collingwood and averaged only 70 points.

But with Ball retiring and Beams gone, is he worth a look at?

Yes his off field dramas is a concern, but  he is a DP player and @ $378,500, he is tempting.

[kilbluff1985]

rather Matt Crouch

[Ricochet]

rather Matt Crouch

Matt Crouch isn't a fwd


At that price mate would probably rather someone like TMitchell. Otherwise I would definitely find more cash and go up to Swan/Martin/etc as its only another 150k and you get a proven premo scorer

[kilbluff1985]

rather Matt Crouch

Matt Crouch isn't a fwd


At that price mate would probably rather someone like TMitchell. Otherwise I would definitely find more cash and go up to Swan/Martin/etc as its only another 150k and you get a proven premo scorer

he didn't say he specifically wanted a forward just that his DPP was a bonus

[JBs-Hawks]

Matt Crouch isnt very good anyway ;)

[kilbluff1985]

Matt Crouch isnt very good anyway ;)

say what?

[Fid]

rather Matt Crouch

Matt Crouch isn't a fwd


At that price mate would probably rather someone like TMitchell. Otherwise I would definitely find more cash and go up to Swan/Martin/etc as its only another 150k and you get a proven premo scorer

Thanks mate, I have Lids and Swan and Bird in the fwds.  I was just thinking who was going to step up at Collingwood both Ball and Beams gone, and I thought of Adams...

[Ricochet]

rather Matt Crouch

Matt Crouch isn't a fwd


At that price mate would probably rather someone like TMitchell. Otherwise I would definitely find more cash and go up to Swan/Martin/etc as its only another 150k and you get a proven premo scorer

he didn't say he specifically wanted a forward just that his DPP was a bonus

It was pretty obvious

[kilbluff1985]

rather Matt Crouch

Matt Crouch isn't a fwd


At that price mate would probably rather someone like TMitchell. Otherwise I would definitely find more cash and go up to Swan/Martin/etc as its only another 150k and you get a proven premo scorer

Thanks mate, I have Lids and Swan and Bird in the fwds.  I was just thinking who was going to step up at Collingwood both Ball and Beams gone, and I thought of Adams...

they got Greenwood and Varcoe also

Adams is a vest candidate each week

[RaisyDaisy]

When looking to try and find a unique mid pricer you really need them to break out into a premo to justify the risk, and I think there are much better options than Adams

Titch is the only cheap forward I would take the risk on, if he lines up rd1

[Hazza09]

Can anyone tell me if Taylor Adams is in Collingwood's best 22?

This for SC Draft only..

Is he worth taking a punt on?

[petefisker]

Hey mate,

Yes Tadams is in our 22.
He's better for DT as he easily gets 23+ possies a game.
His issue is his disposal which affects SC.
He'll play pretty much all games unless his performances really drop off.

[Jroo]

Definitely in the 22.
As Pete said, his kicking is an issue which is affecting his SC scores. Still I think he's a good pick up and if he can improve that, I think he's in for a big year.

[Hazza09]

Thanks boys! SC Draft is harder than what it looks like  :'(

[Silk_Touch]

Definatly in the top 22 has a good role in the forward line and seems to score well