Please rate my SC team...JSales Spankers

[jsales]

Hey all,

This is my first attempt for 2015. Would love any feedback and thoughts, positive or negative. Not sure about the round 12 bye situation with this current line up though...

Defenders: Smith B, Shaw H, Gibson J, Hibberd M, Waters B, Goddard H [Lever J, McGuinness J]
Midfielders: Ablett G, Pendlebury S, Selwood J, Rich D, van Berlo N, Heeney I, Boekhorst B, Freeman N
[Steele J, Krakouer N, Lambert K]
Rucks: Goldstein T, Naitanui N, [Read T]
Forwards: Goddard B,Franklin L, Martin D, Swan D, Bellchambers T, Clark M [Hogan J, Daniel C]

[ben_020285]

Hey all,

This is my first attempt for 2015. Would love any feedback and thoughts, positive or negative. Not sure about the round 12 bye situation with this current line up though...

Defenders: Smith B, Shaw H, Gibson J, Hibberd M, Waters B, Goddard H [Lever J, McGuinness J]
Midfielders: Ablett G, Pendlebury S, Selwood J, Rich D, van Berlo N, Heeney I, Boekhorst B, Freeman N
[Steele J, Krakouer N, Lambert K]
Rucks: Goldstein T, Naitanui N, [Read T]
Forwards: Goddard B,Franklin L, Martin D, Swan D, Bellchambers T, Clark M [Hogan J, Daniel C]

I like the majority of this team. Some really solid picks.

The only things I would change would be Gibson to a breakout contender in the backline. Lever to a cheap rookie. Van Berlo to a cheap rookie. Rich to a premium mid.

[Ricochet]

Hey all,

This is my first attempt for 2015. Would love any feedback and thoughts, positive or negative. Not sure about the round 12 bye situation with this current line up though...

Defenders: Smith B, Shaw H, Gibson J, Hibberd M, Waters B, Goddard H [Lever J, McGuinness J]
Midfielders: Ablett G, Pendlebury S, Selwood J, Rich D, van Berlo N, Heeney I, Boekhorst B, Freeman N
[Steele J, Krakouer N, Lambert K]
Rucks: Goldstein T, Naitanui N, [Read T]
Forwards: Goddard B,Franklin L, Martin D, Swan D, Bellchambers T, Clark M [Hogan J, Daniel C]

DEF: Some good premo selections here mate. Probably better options out there than Josh Gibson though. Someone like KSimpson. Rookies are fine for now but consider Whitecross, MDick and Colquhoun.
MIDS: Think you're a bit light on here. Most teams will go with 4 premos, so you might have to upgrade one here. Rookies are fine at this stage.
RUCKS: Very very strong and good selections.
FWDS: Ok so this is where the cash is at. 4 premos and then Bellchambers is probably too much. Maybe drop one premo down to a rookie and then you can upgrade M4. Hogan can easily be a starting rookie for you and Steele can come down to your fwd bench.

Overrall a good start mate, well done

[NickyBoy]

DEF: Downgrade Gibson to someone else maybe Birchall or Hurn etc. 497k might be too much for him but maybe just wait to see his role in the nab cup with Frawley around now.
MIDS: Too light, you need to have another premium midfielder. I do however like the Daniel Rich pick, he will definitely earn some more money.
RUCKS: Very solid.
FWDS: Too much money. Definitely downgrade 1 to a rookie (maybe Ahmed Saad or Krakeour). That money can be used to grab another premium midfielder. Your rucks might have to take a downgrade to help as well.
Nice team so far. Keep it up.

[jsales]

Hey all,

This is my first attempt for 2015. Would love any feedback and thoughts, positive or negative. Not sure about the round 12 bye situation with this current line up though...

Defenders: Smith B, Shaw H, Simpson K, Hibberd M, Waters B, Goddard H [Wigg H, McGuinness J]
Midfielders: Ablett G, Pendlebury S, Selwood J, Gray R, van Berlo N, Heeney I, Boekhorst B, Freeman N
[Dumont T, Krakouer N, Lambert K]
Rucks: Goldstein T, Naitanui N, [Read T]
Forwards: Goddard B,Franklin L, Martin D, Swan D, Clark M, Hogan J [Steele J, Daniel C]

Thanks for the feedback guys. Have updated as follows;

Def: K Simpson, H Wigg in / J Gibson, J Lever out
Mid: R Gray, T Dumont in / D Rich, J Steele out
Rucks: no change
Fwd: J Steele in / T Bellchambers out

$300 left in the bank.