mitchel/ H Macintosh v Swan/ Tippet

[thornz23]

these are the 2 combos i can afford id say the averages would be around...

Mitchel 100
Swan 115
Hmac 90
Tippet 70

but i would make swan captain instead of bartel giving me an extra 20 as captain probably...
Which combo do you guys think..? is Tippet reliable enough?

[Twin Peaks]

swan and tippet, although i really want HMAC