Ask Noz (Player V Player)

Started by Noz, January 22, 2015, 06:23:45 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Noz

Quote from: powersuperkents on January 23, 2015, 06:58:41 PM
Quote from: Noz on January 23, 2015, 06:38:25 PM
Quote from: powersuperkents on January 23, 2015, 05:39:55 PM
I have two

Pendles or Jelwood

&

Greene or Parker

Pendles, I think he would enjoy the added extra responsibilities in the midfield now that Beams has gone, This could result in a slight increase in points. Selwood should become an upgrade target, I ran some numbers about Selwood and this has become an interesting stat i learnt about him.

In 2013 he averaged 96 in the first half of the season he then went on to average 116 in the second half
In 2014 he averaged 100 in the first half to the season he then went on to average 112 in the second half.

Start with Pendles and then look at bringing in Selwood later on.

After Greene came back from his suspension he went on to average 116 in his last 8 games however Luke Parker is now entering elite company pushing closer and closer in becoming Sydneys best midfielder.

I would go for Parker only because of his ability to push forward and kick goals. Plus Parker can become one of the games elite players by end of year.
Agree with Pendles

Cheers mate

Just one more I need to toss up - Parker or Fyfe - Fyfe is more of a SC player but do you think that this season he can transfer those points into AF?

I agree I think Fyfe can transfer over and become one of AFs super premiums, Would have Fyfe over Parker at this point of the season.

Noz

Quote from: Nige on January 23, 2015, 06:59:15 PM
Adam Treloar vs Dion Prestia, help me please Noz.  :(

Tough but would have to go with Treloar.

Nige

Quote from: Noz on January 23, 2015, 07:18:35 PM
Quote from: Nige on January 23, 2015, 06:59:15 PM
Adam Treloar vs Dion Prestia, help me please Noz.  :(

Tough but would have to go with Treloar.
Planning to go with Prestia in AF, because I've currently got Treloar in my SC.

But that's cool, something to think about. Ideally I only want one in each side, so I've gotta decide somehow!

The_Captain

Quote from: Noz on January 23, 2015, 06:48:28 PM
Quote from: The_Captain on January 23, 2015, 06:05:15 PM
Zorko v Elliot

pls explain.

Cheers Noz

Geez would take a risky man to pick either, Now that Beams, Christensen and Robinson have joined the Lions this could mean less midfield time for Zorko and he may spend more time as a forward. While one man my see less midfield time Elliot would look to get more midfield time.

Wouldn't trust either to improve much on their 2014 average but if I had to pick would have to go with Elliot mainly due to the fact that Brisbane added 3 new guys 2 of which would be capable of pushing Zorko out of the side. If Brisbane can find a way to fit all 4  in the same team together Zorko could be a nice option in the later parts of the season.

There are other options around that price range in which I would look at before these 2.

Thought it'd be an interesting one.., cheers noz

rebird

Mayes or Rampe? Looking at D4/5

Money


Noz

Quote from: rebird on January 23, 2015, 10:25:31 PM
Mayes or Rampe? Looking at D4/5
Rampe with no Malceski Rampe will have more responsibilities set upon him this season and also looking for more midfield time, This could be the year Rampe enters into the premium bracket

Noz

Quote from: Money on January 24, 2015, 06:22:48 PM
Heppell or Jelwood?

Slightly leading more towards Heppell, With Watson still getting the number 1 tag Heppell should be a good selection this year, Had his breakout year last year but I feel theres more to come. Jelwood though he is a good player his second half of the season also is better than his first half.

powersuperkents

Quote from: Noz on January 25, 2015, 02:20:40 AM
Quote from: Money on January 24, 2015, 06:22:48 PM
Heppell or Jelwood?

Slightly leading more towards Heppell, With Watson still getting the number 1 tag Heppell should be a good selection this year, Had his breakout year last year but I feel theres more to come. Jelwood though he is a good player his second half of the season also is better than his first half.
Agree.

Jelwood doesn't look like he will ever be a 110 player until he reaches that 28 peak bracket - if not, ever. Hep D should go +110 this season. Just my personal opinion but he is the games elite seagull and the youngest elite mid in the comp.

powersuperkents

Christian Salem, Ben Lennon or Jack Martin?

Who is the best F6/7/8?

Noz

Quote from: powersuperkents on January 25, 2015, 09:50:09 AM
Quote from: Noz on January 25, 2015, 02:20:40 AM
Quote from: Money on January 24, 2015, 06:22:48 PM
Heppell or Jelwood?

Slightly leading more towards Heppell, With Watson still getting the number 1 tag Heppell should be a good selection this year, Had his breakout year last year but I feel theres more to come. Jelwood though he is a good player his second half of the season also is better than his first half.
Agree.

Jelwood doesn't look like he will ever be a 110 player until he reaches that 28 peak bracket - if not, ever. Hep D should go +110 this season. Just my personal opinion but he is the games elite seagull and the youngest elite mid in the comp.

I just can't justify myself having Jelwood at all, You are paying 600k for a bloke who could never well be your teams captain or leading point scorer, If I am paying 600k for someone I would want for him to either be an established super premium or someone who is looking to break into that elite bracket, Jelwood doesn't fill me with confidence

Noz

Quote from: powersuperkents on January 25, 2015, 09:52:35 AM
Christian Salem, Ben Lennon or Jack Martin?

Who is the best F6/7/8?

All 3 in my opinion set to have pretty good years. I currently have Jack Martin and personally im not sure why more people don't have him. He was in everyones teams last year and he is only 20k more expensive then at the start of last season.

Martin is capable of having one of the biggest point increase this year as I can see him putting 20-25 points more on his average and will be in Gold Coast best 22. With Martin its not a discussion of if he will be a premium its just when.

Lennon looked good at points last year when coming on, Is facing a lot of competition for that small/mid sized forward role. Has the talent to cement a spot in the side. Could be more vests coming his way in the early parts of the season though

Salem will be a gun as well, Looks towards the middle part of the year he was ready to cement his positon in the starting 22. Seems a huge candidate to receive the vest and would want to wait to see how the addition of Pettracca and where that will leave Salem. Watch in the pre season to see what role he is playing for the club.

Martin > Lennon > Salem

powersuperkents

Quote from: Noz on January 25, 2015, 10:16:35 AM
Quote from: powersuperkents on January 25, 2015, 09:52:35 AM
Christian Salem, Ben Lennon or Jack Martin?

Who is the best F6/7/8?

All 3 in my opinion set to have pretty good years. I currently have Jack Martin and personally im not sure why more people don't have him. He was in everyones teams last year and he is only 20k more expensive then at the start of last season.

Martin is capable of having one of the biggest point increase this year as I can see him putting 20-25 points more on his average and will be in Gold Coast best 22. With Martin its not a discussion of if he will be a premium its just when.

Lennon looked good at points last year when coming on, Is facing a lot of competition for that small/mid sized forward role. Has the talent to cement a spot in the side. Could be more vests coming his way in the early parts of the season though

Salem will be a gun as well, Looks towards the middle part of the year he was ready to cement his positon in the starting 22. Seems a huge candidate to receive the vest and would want to wait to see how the addition of Pettracca and where that will leave Salem. Watch in the pre season to see what role he is playing for the club.

Martin > Lennon > Salem
Cheers man

Solves my midfield dilemma. If I went Lennon or Salem I would have any mid available for M4 (too much choice - too much risk). If I select Martin it is just a decision between Fyfe (want a Freo mid) or Parker to toss up between - so far siding with Parker because he just needs to reduce the amount of free kicks he gives away to become an elite fantasy mid.

Noz

Quote from: powersuperkents on January 25, 2015, 10:20:10 AM
Quote from: Noz on January 25, 2015, 10:16:35 AM
Quote from: powersuperkents on January 25, 2015, 09:52:35 AM
Christian Salem, Ben Lennon or Jack Martin?

Who is the best F6/7/8?

All 3 in my opinion set to have pretty good years. I currently have Jack Martin and personally im not sure why more people don't have him. He was in everyones teams last year and he is only 20k more expensive then at the start of last season.

Martin is capable of having one of the biggest point increase this year as I can see him putting 20-25 points more on his average and will be in Gold Coast best 22. With Martin its not a discussion of if he will be a premium its just when.

Lennon looked good at points last year when coming on, Is facing a lot of competition for that small/mid sized forward role. Has the talent to cement a spot in the side. Could be more vests coming his way in the early parts of the season though

Salem will be a gun as well, Looks towards the middle part of the year he was ready to cement his positon in the starting 22. Seems a huge candidate to receive the vest and would want to wait to see how the addition of Pettracca and where that will leave Salem. Watch in the pre season to see what role he is playing for the club.

Martin > Lennon > Salem
Cheers man

Solves my midfield dilemma. If I went Lennon or Salem I would have any mid available for M4 (too much choice - too much risk). If I select Martin it is just a decision between Fyfe (want a Freo mid) or Parker to toss up between - so far siding with Parker because he just needs to reduce the amount of free kicks he gives away to become an elite fantasy mid.

Yeah Parker can be a bit wonky with his frees but his ability to push forward and kicks goals is a great addition. Like I previously said in the earlier post he is ready to break into that elite bracket of midfielders now. Especially after his final series.

powersuperkents

Quote from: Noz on January 25, 2015, 10:31:46 AM
Quote from: powersuperkents on January 25, 2015, 10:20:10 AM
Quote from: Noz on January 25, 2015, 10:16:35 AM
Quote from: powersuperkents on January 25, 2015, 09:52:35 AM
Christian Salem, Ben Lennon or Jack Martin?

Who is the best F6/7/8?

All 3 in my opinion set to have pretty good years. I currently have Jack Martin and personally im not sure why more people don't have him. He was in everyones teams last year and he is only 20k more expensive then at the start of last season.

Martin is capable of having one of the biggest point increase this year as I can see him putting 20-25 points more on his average and will be in Gold Coast best 22. With Martin its not a discussion of if he will be a premium its just when.

Lennon looked good at points last year when coming on, Is facing a lot of competition for that small/mid sized forward role. Has the talent to cement a spot in the side. Could be more vests coming his way in the early parts of the season though

Salem will be a gun as well, Looks towards the middle part of the year he was ready to cement his positon in the starting 22. Seems a huge candidate to receive the vest and would want to wait to see how the addition of Pettracca and where that will leave Salem. Watch in the pre season to see what role he is playing for the club.

Martin > Lennon > Salem
Cheers man

Solves my midfield dilemma. If I went Lennon or Salem I would have any mid available for M4 (too much choice - too much risk). If I select Martin it is just a decision between Fyfe (want a Freo mid) or Parker to toss up between - so far siding with Parker because he just needs to reduce the amount of free kicks he gives away to become an elite fantasy mid.

Yeah Parker can be a bit wonky with his frees but his ability to push forward and kicks goals is a great addition. Like I previously said in the earlier post he is ready to break into that elite bracket of midfielders now. Especially after his final series.
His low ownership rate is nice as well  ;)