Ask Noz (Player V Player)

[Noz]

Figured I may start up a topic, Helping out guys if they are on the fence in which players to choose.

[Football Factory]

Elliot Yeo  vs  Ricky Henderson

Thanks Noz

[Noz]

Elliot Yeo  vs  Ricky Henderson

Thanks Noz

More entitled to go for Yeo, Showed a bit of promise last year and entering his 4th year in the AFL could be ready to break out, Would have slightly better job security then Henderson, too.

I don't see Henderson in Adelaides best 22

[Football Factory]

Elliot Yeo  vs  Ricky Henderson

Thanks Noz

More entitled to go for Yeo, Showed a bit of promise last year and entering his 4th year in the AFL could be ready to break out, Would have slightly better job security then Henderson, too.

I don't see Henderson in Adelaides best 22

I have Yeo at the moment but only recently, Henderson seems injury prone which has me leaning towards Yeo.

[nrich102]

Hey Noz, who would you go for out of Kreuzer and Leuenberger? Cheers buddy.

[quinny88]

Dustin Martin V Chad Wingard  ;D

[Noz]

Hey Noz, who would you go for out of Kreuzer and Leuenberger? Cheers buddy.

Kreuzer without a doubt.

A bit of risk comes with both players no doubt Leuey has a slightly worse injury record and Brisbane would want to ease him back in the fold especially with Martin close to emerging as the clubs best ruckman so Leuey may spend more time up forward due to the lack of key forwards Brisbane have a lack of talls up there. First half of the season you would say Leuey would only ruck 40% of games with Martin rucking the other 60%.

Kreuzer on the other hand will look to ruck at least 80% of the time and that would result in more points.

I just see Brisbane taking a more careful approach to Leuey then Carlton will with Kreuzer

[Noz]

Dustin Martin V Chad Wingard  ;D

Chad Wingard by the length of flemington straight.

All jokes aside though I would actually start with Martin over Chad,  :o, Wingards final series really frustrated me as his lack of consistency continues to be a major problem in his development. If Chad can find his consistency I can see him average around the 85-90 but for the fact Martin has found more consistency in his game you would have to slightly lead towards him. However if you are picking Martin of Lids then your insane.

Wingard will still be in the top 5 forwards come end of the year so he is still a must

[quinny88]

Dustin Martin V Chad Wingard  ;D

Chad Wingard by the length of flemington straight.

All jokes aside though I would actually start with Martin over Chad,  :o, Wingards final series really frustrated me as his lack of consistency continues to be a major problem in his development. If Chad can find his consistency I can see him average around the 85-90 but for the fact Martin has found more consistency in his game you would have to slightly lead towards him. However if you are picking Martin of Lids then your insane.

Wingard will still be in the top 5 forwards come end of the year so he is still a must

Haha that must have been hard for you :P

Why lids over Dusty though? Dusty has outscored him past 2 seasons and still improving whereas lids probably shown his best.
Will have both eventually but will be starting Dusty I think

[pommyadam]

Hurn + Bellchambers or Yeo + Lycett (as D3 and F3/4)

[T Dog]

At the top $ end of things Noz what choice between Rockliff and Ablett as a R1 starter please mate

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Jack Newnes or Brodie Smith?

[Noz]

Hurn + Bellchambers or Yeo + Lycett (as D3 and F3/4)

Lycett did end the year on a good note averaging 82 in the second half of the season including 6 scores over 80 but I just can't justify his price tag at $410,000 especially for a bloke who won't be the number 1 ruck man at the club. Yeo primed for a break out year though.

Hurn now the captain of the Eagles is more of a supercoach player but with only 5 scores above 100 in his past 37 games I wouldn't want to be relying on him as my D3. Bellchambers is at a very nice price for what he can produce but has been very injury prone.

I would take the punt on Bellchambers as a F3/4 but would look for another option for my D3 someone who is a bit more reliable.

[Noz]

At the top $ end of things Noz what choice between Rockliff and Ablett as a R1 starter please mate

Ablett mainly because I would want to wait and see how the addition of Danye Beams will effect Rockliffs scoring.

[Capper]

Westhoff v Lecras