Player X v Player Y

[dicko_]

Not sure if this is quite the right thread but do I stick with Lewis or trade him to a Heppell/Hanneberry/Shiel/Priddis?
Also Walker out for Buddy or Goddard or Dalhaus?

Unless you are trying to win overall there isn't much point in trading Lewis, since he has been very solid so far.
Out of those options, probably Goddard, because he is a known quantity, but Dahlhaus could become a very solid option judging from his scores so far this year. Has been in the system long enough and is getting a fair amount of mid time.

Also JPK + Ziebell v Parker + Goddard

[Jroo]

Motlop vs ziebell??

motlop -better scorer and better sense of self preservation

Doesn't know when a good time to have a beer is though :P

What? It's always a good time for a beer :P

[TexR74]

Not sure if this is quite the right thread but do I stick with Lewis or trade him to a Heppell/Hanneberry/Shiel/Priddis?
Also Walker out for Buddy or Goddard or Dalhaus?

Unless you are trying to win overall there isn't much point in trading Lewis, since he has been very solid so far.
Out of those options, probably Goddard, because he is a known quantity, but Dahlhaus could become a very solid option judging from his scores so far this year. Has been in the system long enough and is getting a fair amount of mid time.

Also JPK + Ziebell v Parker + Goddard

Second option, not sold on Ziebell

[H1bb3i2d]

I dont know how Titch affects JPKs scores?

In 2013, JPK's scores were 147, 108, 136, 80, 109, 102, 143, 151 and 56 before mitchell got a game

In the games mitchell played for the rest of the year... JPK scored 126, 86, 107, 88, 96, 107, 108, 82, 68, 93, 89 and 101

He didn't manage a big score other than Mitchell's first game

And the thing that added more suspicion to the theory is that the one game mitchell didn't play after round 10, which was round 21, JPK scored 136!

That was 2013 though. THe players have grown/changed, the team has changed, the opposition have changed. I wouldn't read too much into it

Are you saying that Titch affected JPK's score the the 2013 SF as well? JPK only scored 113 and Titch only played 15 minutes??

If you look at the stats From Rounds 1-9 and then 10-23, JPK, Dan Han and Jack all had smaller scores in 10-23 than 1-9

Didn't it also come out after the season finished in 2013 that Kennedy was carrying a quad or hamstring injury for the second half of the year? I'm sure I read that somewhere..

Yep. Was a groin or adductor or something that he managed, but he just struggled to kick the footy and became a handball machine.

I also agree with the point in there that 2013 is a long time ago in footy.

[Keeper27]

Need help, please. trading out Parker/wines/Jong.
sick of parker losing money and wines not scoring on the pine.

1) Parker/wines to Mundy/Hannerbery
2) Parker/wines to Pendles/Armitage
3) Jong/wines to JPK/Neale (keep Parker He'll come good... Hopefully)
4) other (any 2 premos under $1,213,600)

thanks heaps fellas

[honza]

Yep. Was a groin or adductor or something that he managed, but he just struggled to kick the footy and became a handball machine.

I also agree with the point in there that 2013 is a long time ago in footy.

Correct on the groin, it's a long term conditioning thing. He's effectively on managed loads now which brought his numbers back up.

[GoLions]

Need help, please. trading out Parker/wines/Jong.
sick of parker losing money and wines not scoring on the pine.

1) Parker/wines to Mundy/Hannerbery
2) Parker/wines to Pendles/Armitage
3) Jong/wines to JPK/Neale (keep Parker He'll come good... Hopefully)
4) other (any 2 premos under $1,213,600)

thanks heaps fellas

I'd get Pendles, and then maybe a premo fwd if you have DPP to do so

[Keeper27]

Already got 4 premo fwds. Gray/dusty/swanny and bonts.
Just went jong to JPK.
I'll worry about wines in a couple of weeks, and hope parker can get back to 100+
Next week double downgrade.

Mids now look like this.
Fyfe. Shiel. JPK. Danger. Parker. CEY. VDB. Miller. (Wines. Newton. Krakouer)

[Holden the ball]

newnes to who

[Thewizz71]

newnes to who

Who've you got?

[MC]

Barlow vs K Jack (SC draft choice!)

[Holden the ball]

newnes to who

Who've you got?

saad, mcintosh, oxley, rance, shaw, mckenzie, brown

[TexR74]

newnes to who

Who've you got?

saad, mcintosh, oxley, rance, shaw, mckenzie, brown

I'd go a slightly left-field option and look at murphy from the doggies, has been playing well and has dees, giants and saints in 3 of his next 5

[swans15]

Trade in Goddard & Shiel vs Bont and Watson

[Ricochet]

Trade in Goddard & Shiel vs Bont and Watson

How does it affect your byes mate? Guessing Shiel would be handy with the RD13