Player X v Player Y

[batt]

Who should I keep
Newnes or Hunt?

I'm keeping Newnes and trading Hunt.  Can't give up on Newnes yet.  Hasn't had a big game.

[Spotted gum]

Motlop vs ziebell??

[Asparagus]

Goddard vs Bontempelli????

[PICCOLLO]

Goddard vs Bontempelli????

Goddard. Has the experience and years of scores to back it up.  Bont might fade as his body is still developing into an 'AFL body'

[Thewizz71]

Goddard vs Bontempelli????

Goddard. Has the experience and years of scores to back it up.  Bont might fade as his body is still developing into an 'AFL body'

Agree. Goddard or Gray this week.

[TexR74]

Not sure if this is quite the right thread but do I stick with Lewis or trade him to a Heppell/Hanneberry/Shiel/Priddis?
Also Walker out for Buddy or Goddard or Dalhaus?

[Capper]

I dont know how Titch affects JPKs scores?

In 2013, JPK's scores were 147, 108, 136, 80, 109, 102, 143, 151 and 56 before mitchell got a game

In the games mitchell played for the rest of the year... JPK scored 126, 86, 107, 88, 96, 107, 108, 82, 68, 93, 89 and 101

He didn't manage a big score other than Mitchell's first game

And the thing that added more suspicion to the theory is that the one game mitchell didn't play after round 10, which was round 21, JPK scored 136!

That was 2013 though. THe players have grown/changed, the team has changed, the opposition have changed. I wouldn't read too much into it

Are you saying that Titch affected JPK's score the the 2013 SF as well? JPK only scored 113 and Titch only played 15 minutes??

If you look at the stats From Rounds 1-9 and then 10-23, JPK, Dan Han and Jack all had smaller scores in 10-23 than 1-9

[jfitty]

I dont know how Titch affects JPKs scores?

In 2013, JPK's scores were 147, 108, 136, 80, 109, 102, 143, 151 and 56 before mitchell got a game

In the games mitchell played for the rest of the year... JPK scored 126, 86, 107, 88, 96, 107, 108, 82, 68, 93, 89 and 101

He didn't manage a big score other than Mitchell's first game

And the thing that added more suspicion to the theory is that the one game mitchell didn't play after round 10, which was round 21, JPK scored 136!

That was 2013 though. THe players have grown/changed, the team has changed, the opposition have changed. I wouldn't read too much into it

Are you saying that Titch affected JPK's score the the 2013 SF as well? JPK only scored 113 and Titch only played 15 minutes??

If you look at the stats From Rounds 1-9 and then 10-23, JPK, Dan Han and Jack all had smaller scores in 10-23 than 1-9

Didn't it also come out after the season finished in 2013 that Kennedy was carrying a quad or hamstring injury for the second half of the year? I'm sure I read that somewhere..

[Samsturmfels]

Ziebell vs Tmitch

[BomberSam]

Ziebell vs Tmitch

Ziebell on the basis of job security. You never know when Titch will be out, despite his awesome talent.

[Degsman]

Very good points guys, just an observation I made during 2013 when I was annoyed with JPK's scoring, perhaps it doesn't all come down to tmitch.

[HotTiges]

Goddard vs Ryder vs Dahlhaus

[jfitty]

Goddard vs Ryder vs Dahlhaus

I'm also picking between these guys and Buddy.

Really want Dahlhaus, but will probably go Goodard the proven one 

[johnoP]

Motlop vs ziebell??

motlop -better scorer and better sense of self preservation

[_wato]

Motlop vs ziebell??

motlop -better scorer and better sense of self preservation

Doesn't know when a good time to have a beer is though :P