Player X v Player Y

[Capper]

Best replacement for Lewis: Heppell/Shiel/Hanneberry or hold

see what he gets, 3+ trade

That's what i thought, but if he does get 3+ who should i get in?

are u actually retarded he hust legit gave u 3 options

not too sure who you are calling retarded but thats a bit rough.

Who are your other mids? Out of the 3 mentioned i would go Hanners or you could go with Shiel for a POD. Heppell you can get for cheaper in about 4 weeks

[TexR74]

Best replacement for Lewis: Heppell/Shiel/Hanneberry or hold

see what he gets, 3+ trade

That's what i thought, but if he does get 3+ who should i get in?

are u actually retarded he hust legit gave u 3 options

not too sure who you are calling retarded but thats a bit rough.

Who are your other mids? Out of the 3 mentioned i would go Hanners or you could go with Shiel for a POD. Heppell you can get for cheaper in about 4 weeks

Mids are: Fyfe, Pendles, Sloane, Swan/Gray/Bont (two in the fwds) and Lewis

[plumdog millionaire]

Bob Murphy v Grant Birchall

[roti]

The 172 will be out of his 3 week average after this week which could be why

[YoungGun]

Bob Murphy v Grant Birchall

Bob, especially if the dogs keep on playing good footy. They love it in his hands, I got burnt by him last year but the dogs are a much better team this year

[no eye deer]

The 172 will be out of his 3 week average after this week which could be why

Ah, ok. I forgot about that score.

[honza]

Bob Murphy v Grant Birchall

Bob.

Birchall can be a massive burn man when he feels like it.

[Degsman]

Birchall vs Tmac vs Pittard

                and

         Shiel vs JPK

[Ricochet]

Birchall vs Tmac vs Pittard

                and

         Shiel vs JPK

Birchall and JPK.

I tend to always lean towards proven performers

[Degsman]

Birchall vs Tmac vs Pittard

                and

         Shiel vs JPK

Birchall and JPK.

I tend to always lean towards proven performers

I am thinking that too Ricochet, but JPK's scores with mitchell in the team have burned me before.
So the mitchell factor is turning me off

[Capper]

I dont know how Titch affects JPKs scores?

[Ricochet]

Birchall vs Tmac vs Pittard

                and

         Shiel vs JPK

Birchall and JPK.

I tend to always lean towards proven performers

I am thinking that too Ricochet, but JPK's scores with mitchell in the team have burned me before.
So the mitchell factor is turning me off

JPKs scores with TMitchell
2015 - 101
2014  - 91, 109, 110, 120

I wouldn't be too concerned mate, the sample size is too small

[Degsman]

I dont know how Titch affects JPKs scores?

In 2013, JPK's scores were 147, 108, 136, 80, 109, 102, 143, 151 and 56 before mitchell got a game

In the games mitchell played for the rest of the year... JPK scored 126, 86, 107, 88, 96, 107, 108, 82, 68, 93, 89 and 101

He didn't manage a big score other than Mitchell's first game

And the thing that added more suspicion to the theory is that the one game mitchell didn't play after round 10, which was round 21, JPK scored 136!

[Ricochet]

I dont know how Titch affects JPKs scores?

In 2013, JPK's scores were 147, 108, 136, 80, 109, 102, 143, 151 and 56 before mitchell got a game

In the games mitchell played for the rest of the year... JPK scored 126, 86, 107, 88, 96, 107, 108, 82, 68, 93, 89 and 101

He didn't manage a big score other than Mitchell's first game

And the thing that added more suspicion to the theory is that the one game mitchell didn't play after round 10, which was round 21, JPK scored 136!

That was 2013 though. THe players have grown/changed, the team has changed, the opposition have changed. I wouldn't read too much into it

[Samsturmfels]

Who should I keep
Newnes or Hunt?