Player X v Player Y

[bottlemart]

If both start on field I would definitely go Anderson, he's older and I think will be a better scorer, but Cocky may have better JS, not sure, that remains to be seen.  But if both on field or both sub, I would go Anderson.

[enzedder]

I've gone Cocky.

[Rusty00]

I've always had Cockatoo but starting to think if Anderson is not sub I'll make the switch.

Any little money saving could be helpful ;)

[honza]

I just went with both...

[bottlemart]

So Lewis and Cockatoo and 34k or Selwood and J Anderson And 9k in the bank?

Leaning towards A as Selwood does have some lean games so have in the past been able to get him cheaper at some point. Also Cockatoo seems to have better job security.

Personally I would go with Selwood and Anderson.  Selwood has been a proven performer, last 3 years he has averaged about 117, 118, and 120 or thereabouts, may have some lean games and could be cheaper, but should also have some very big scores.  I like Anderson over Cocky, mainly an age thing there.  Anderson at 21 years 2 months, Cocky at 18 years 5 months, traditionally the better scorers are players who are that bit older than the 1st year rookies.  Think Barlow at 21 in his first year with Freo.

[zac-ster]

Last mid spot between Anderson and Cockatoo. Leaning towards Cockatoo as I think he has better js.

[Bully]

In the end I would rather have the extra dough so Anderson gets the nod.

[TexR74]

Is there any chance that Lewis could score more than Selwood in this match?

[Jackross10]

Is there any chance that Lewis could score more than Selwood in this match?

Yes but I'd say 30% chance

[HotTiges]

Is there any chance that Lewis could score more than Selwood in this match?

half thinking about going Selwood to Lewis to free up cash

[Swoozie]

Anderson starting as sub. So assuming you don't have both Anderson to Cockatoo is now looking like a must.

[bkp130]

IM really tempted of going selwood to lewis + cash. Just have the feeling lewis is going to go bigger

Have absoloutley no reason to think that other than gut feel though

[jfitty]

IM really tempted of going selwood to lewis + cash. Just have the feeling lewis is going to go bigger

Have absoloutley no reason to think that other than gut feel though

I'm tempted to do this as well, free up some cash for a couple of corrective trades

[bkp130]

Yeah thats what im thinking

but im looking at selwoods last 10 games last year vs lewis. Massive difference

Although lewis scored more in the NAB cup.

Lewis could go big. He has more players in the middle to support him even though he will probobly get the tag.  Also 24 Percent of teams have Selwood

Could be a good POD grabbing lewis.

Dont know if i have the balls though

[TexR74]

IM really tempted of going selwood to lewis + cash. Just have the feeling lewis is going to go bigger

Have absoloutley no reason to think that other than gut feel though

That's what I've just done, think he could provide an edge with a close-to-POD ownership % I think?