Player X v Player Y

[_wato]

Simple question, please give honest opinions based on scoring output and job security

Wells + Newton v Steven + Vandenberg

Already have Cripps, Cockatoo, Heeney, CEY and Miller

[Rusty00]

Simple question, please give honest opinions based on scoring output and job security

Wells + Newton v Steven + Vandenberg

Already have Cripps, Cockatoo, Heeney, CEY and Miller

Tough one as most are struggling with which of the mid rookies to pick. I would probably go Steven + Vandenburg as I think Steven will average more than Wells and I think Newton and Vandenburg are pretty similar JS and scoring wise.

[Rusty00]

Steven + Swan vs Ward/Beams + Bellchambers

Have had the first option for some time now, but am starting to like the second option as it gives me a secure keeper as opposed to 2 "value picks" and also gives me ruck backup?

[Blues Blues Blues]

Hogan v Lonie

[Bully]

Simple question, please give honest opinions based on scoring output and job security

Wells + Newton v Steven + Vandenberg

Already have Cripps, Cockatoo, Heeney, CEY and Miller

Tough one as most are struggling with which of the mid rookies to pick. I would probably go Steven + Vandenburg as I think Steven will average more than Wells and I think Newton and Vandenburg are pretty similar JS and scoring wise.

Agree, Steven should go 100+ whereas that's probably Wells ceiling. I guess that only issue here is the prospect of Vandenberg needing a corrective trade, at least Newton has a ton of other options to switch to. I'd probably leave a bit in the kitty to grab an Anderson or Garlett if need be.

[Fid]

Simple question, please give honest opinions based on scoring output and job security

Wells + Newton v Steven + Vandenberg

Already have Cripps, Cockatoo, Heeney, CEY and Miller

That's a tough one, as I don't know if any of them are keepers.

That's is the question with these mid pricers....

You could even throw in Rich + Sinclair???

I would look to see who has the green vest with the Melbourne two and then pick the player you can afford.

[Rusty00]

I would look to see who has the green vest with the Melbourne two and then pick the player you can afford.

This is going to be a key to a lot of decisions :-\

[HotTiges]

I would look to see who has the green vest with the Melbourne two and then pick the player you can afford.

This is going to be a key to a lot of decisions :-\

be nice if Brayshaw and Vanders avoid vest

[dmac07]

F3 - Franklin or Bennell. Whos better to start?

Already have gray, martin, swan

[blackrose]

Newnes vs. Lumumba

[Doggoneit]

Hogan v Lonie

I've got the same decision

unfortunately won't know final Monday teams before kickoff

[Bully]

Goldstein vs Gray (and no ruck back-up)

[HotTiges]

Goldstein vs Gray (and no ruck back-up)

Gray..

Mine is..

Bartel vs Swan

[Puppetry]

Goldstein vs Gray (and no ruck back-up)

Gray..

Mine is..

Bartel vs Swan

Swan

Mine is J Kelly vs H Taylor in defence.....

[mark44]

Jack lonie or armad saad?