Player X v Player Y

[Frankfaust1]

I'd love some thoughts on Buddy vs Swan vs Goddard.

Have swan, can afford Buddy. Like the look of Buddy in the line-up, but worried that Swan is cheap and better value.

Thanks for any thoughts.

[blackrose]

Swan + H. Taylor
     OR
Gray + B. Goodes

Gray and Goodes

Newnes vs lumumba

[Fid]

Okley (D7) + B Goddard (F3) + Lonie (F7) - have Saad D8

V

Brown (D7) + Swan (F4)  + Hogan (F7)

Just getting a little cold feet with Swanny

[BomberSam]

Just a quick poll, who should I pick, Beams or Selwood?

[Jackross10]

Post in x vs y but selly

[GoLions]

Depends on the rest of your mids, I like having both as there's not many other mids from R11 and R13 byes that I want to start with, whereas there are a heap in R12

I'd probably go with Jelly over Beams if I could only pick 1 though

[Rodi]

Gibson v Hodge?

[GoLions]

Gibson v Hodge?

I'd take Gibbo

[Jackross10]

Gibson v Hodge?

I'd take Gibbo

+1

[ryanbob0357]

Goodes (D5), Goddard (M5 but pushing to FWDS down track), Lonie (F6 or bench)

vs

Brown (D5 or bench), Gray (F1), Vandenberg (bench)

[monga77]

Heeney v CEY

[madskill55]

Lonie or Ahmed Saad? who will score better?

toss of a coin really...

[FactHunt]

Heeney v CEY

[TexR74]

Newnes/Sheed vs Oxley/Griffen

[FactHunt]

Newnes/Sheed vs Oxley/Griffen

You got a line on Oxley's JS?.. him with Griff looks mighty enticing there