Player X v Player Y

[NickyBoy]

Higgins vs Newnes

[Southstorm]

Higgins vs Newnes

Higgins has a higher ceiling but there wouldn't be a bloke in Australia who he hasn't burned. I took Newnes.

[blackrose]

really cant decide between kade simpson and hibberd  :o

[TexR74]

Brown vs Oxley

[bowyanger]

Brown vs Oxley

WTF?

[Hoggyz_a_legend]

Newton v Brayshaw v Cockatoo.

Job security and scoring potential seem similar to me...

[bowyanger]

Newton v Brayshaw v Cockatoo.

Job security and scoring potential seem similar to me...

Newton

Roos is not an advocate of baptism in fire for young fellahs (well, prolonged baptisms anyways), Girlong have a luxury to an extent of not flogging their gifted young blokes so would rest them when they get sore also

Newton is a bit older = more durable

I wouldn't pick any of them though

[TexR74]

Brown vs Oxley

WTF?

Soo...
Which one?

[Hoggyz_a_legend]

Newton v Brayshaw v Cockatoo.

Job security and scoring potential seem similar to me...

Newton

Roos is not an advocate of baptism in fire for young fellahs (well, prolonged baptisms anyways), Girlong have a luxury to an extent of not flogging their gifted young blokes so would rest them when they get sore also

Newton is a bit older = more durable

I wouldn't pick any of them though

So if none of them, Vandenberg v Anderson?

[HotTiges]

Newton v Brayshaw v Cockatoo.

Job security and scoring potential seem similar to me...

Newton

Roos is not an advocate of baptism in fire for young fellahs (well, prolonged baptisms anyways), Girlong have a luxury to an extent of not flogging their gifted young blokes so would rest them when they get sore also

Newton is a bit older = more durable

I wouldn't pick any of them though

So if none of them, Vandenberg v Anderson?

Vandenberg.. I'm not sure Anderson will make the cut even..

Clancee vs Ibbotson

[Big Mac]

Newton v Brayshaw v Cockatoo.

Job security and scoring potential seem similar to me...

Newton

Roos is not an advocate of baptism in fire for young fellahs (well, prolonged baptisms anyways), Girlong have a luxury to an extent of not flogging their gifted young blokes so would rest them when they get sore also

Newton is a bit older = more durable

I wouldn't pick any of them though

So if none of them, Vandenberg v Anderson?

Vandenberg.. I'm not sure Anderson will make the cut even..

Clancee vs Ibbotson

Have Ibbotson at the moment - Think he can average 80+ but can't say the same for Pearce

[Samsturmfels]

Brown vs Oxley

WTF?

Soo...
Which one?

I need to know the same thing

[dmac07]

Brown vs Oxley

WTF?

Soo...
Which one?

I need to know the same thing

Same problem. Oxley. If you're a risk taker. Im thinking both on my bench. Mcintosh and saad on the ground.


Ibbotson, Goldstein, Tarrent/Hogan or Saad, Nic Nat, Bennell
Saad and Hogan already on bench, would move to ground.

[HotTiges]

Brown vs Oxley

WTF?

Soo...
Which one?

I need to know the same thing

Same problem. Oxley. If you're a risk taker. Im thinking both on my bench. Mcintosh and saad on the ground.


Ibbotson, Goldstein, Tarrent/Hogan or Saad, Nic Nat, Bennell
Saad and Hogan already on bench, would move to ground.

not the only one excited by Mac's score.. free's up so much cash

[Bully]

Brown vs Oxley

WTF?

Soo...
Which one?

I need to know the same thing

Same problem. Oxley. If you're a risk taker. Im thinking both on my bench. Mcintosh and saad on the ground.


Ibbotson, Goldstein, Tarrent/Hogan or Saad, Nic Nat, Bennell
Saad and Hogan already on bench, would move to ground.

I have both there now, after tonight's performance by KMac I'm very open to playing two rookies in defence.