Player X v Player Y

[TexR74]

1. Gibbs vs Murphy vs Heppell vs Watson vs Cotchin vs any mid under $578k

2. Newton vs Brayshaw

Also, what is the ownership % for Newton and Brayshaw?

Newton - 11.94%

Brayshaw - 8.92%

And also the % for gibbs, cotchin and griffen? Thanks so much

Gibbs - 1.65%
Cotchin - 4.69%
Griffen - 17.28%

Legendary. What are the pros and cons with Gibbs?

[Fid]

1. Gibbs vs Murphy vs Heppell vs Watson vs Cotchin vs any mid under $578k

2. Newton vs Brayshaw

Also, what is the ownership % for Newton and Brayshaw?

Newton - 11.94%

Brayshaw - 8.92%

And also the % for gibbs, cotchin and griffen? Thanks so much

Gibbs - 1.65%
Cotchin - 4.69%
Griffen - 17.28%

Legendary. What are the pros and cons with Gibbs?

Pros -
POD
Rarely gets injured (Played 177 games out of a possible 182 since debut)
Has increased his midfield time (played 82% last season up from 56%) - hence is average SC score has increased from 96 to 106.

Cons -
Lost  his DPP

[TexR74]

1. Gibbs vs Murphy vs Heppell vs Watson vs Cotchin vs any mid under $578k

2. Newton vs Brayshaw

Also, what is the ownership % for Newton and Brayshaw?

Newton - 11.94%

Brayshaw - 8.92%

And also the % for gibbs, cotchin and griffen? Thanks so much

Gibbs - 1.65%
Cotchin - 4.69%
Griffen - 17.28%

Legendary. What are the pros and cons with Gibbs?

Pros -
POD
Rarely gets injured (Played 177 games out of a possible 182 since debut)
Has increased his midfield time (played 82% last season up from 56%) - hence is average SC score has increased from 96 to 106.

Cons -
Lost  his DPP

Great, I think that he could be a humungous POD. What's Dangerfield's ownership %? I think that it will be one of these two

[Fid]

1. Gibbs vs Murphy vs Heppell vs Watson vs Cotchin vs any mid under $578k

2. Newton vs Brayshaw

Also, what is the ownership % for Newton and Brayshaw?

Newton - 11.94%

Brayshaw - 8.92%

And also the % for gibbs, cotchin and griffen? Thanks so much

Gibbs - 1.65%
Cotchin - 4.69%
Griffen - 17.28%

Legendary. What are the pros and cons with Gibbs?

Pros -
POD
Rarely gets injured (Played 177 games out of a possible 182 since debut)
Has increased his midfield time (played 82% last season up from 56%) - hence is average SC score has increased from 96 to 106.

Cons -
Lost  his DPP

Great, I think that he could be a humungous POD. What's Dangerfield's ownership %? I think that it will be one of these two

Dangerfield - 14.05%

[TexR74]

1. Gibbs vs Murphy vs Heppell vs Watson vs Cotchin vs any mid under $578k

2. Newton vs Brayshaw

Also, what is the ownership % for Newton and Brayshaw?

Newton - 11.94%

Brayshaw - 8.92%

And also the % for gibbs, cotchin and griffen? Thanks so much

Gibbs - 1.65%
Cotchin - 4.69%
Griffen - 17.28%

Legendary. What are the pros and cons with Gibbs?

Pros -
POD
Rarely gets injured (Played 177 games out of a possible 182 since debut)
Has increased his midfield time (played 82% last season up from 56%) - hence is average SC score has increased from 96 to 106.

Cons -
Lost  his DPP

Great, I think that he could be a humungous POD. What's Dangerfield's ownership %? I think that it will be one of these two

Dangerfield - 14.05%

So all up, is Gibbs a good pick for a POD?

[Fid]

Just my opinion, I'd still go Dangerfield. 

[Mat0369]

From memory last season Gibbs either went really well or really poorly in terms of SC scoring. There was no middle ground, but having said that, his scores improved when he seemed to make up his mind and the contract issues were put behind him. So after the first month of footy he had a spike in his production and became a really good option as a mid 8 type player (I think he averaged 110 around that point). He will stay in the guts and with Juddy and Carrots back that will help his scoring as he will be able to roam freely. You just have to expect the odd clunker somewhere in there but he could further improve his consistency this season

[Mark]

Ward or N.Jones or Priddis ??

[TexR74]

From memory last season Gibbs either went really well or really poorly in terms of SC scoring. There was no middle ground, but having said that, his scores improved when he seemed to make up his mind and the contract issues were put behind him. So after the first month of footy he had a spike in his production and became a really good option as a mid 8 type player (I think he averaged 110 around that point). He will stay in the guts and with Juddy and Carrots back that will help his scoring as he will be able to roam freely. You just have to expect the odd clunker somewhere in there but he could further improve his consistency this season

So all up, Gibbs seems like he will improve, but enough to fend off other mids like Cotchin, Prestia and of course, Dangefield?

[Big Mac]

Ward or N.Jones or Priddis ??

Ward

[Mat0369]

So all up, Gibbs seems like he will improve, but enough to fend off other mids like Cotchin, Prestia and of course, Dangefield?

Prestia is the interesting one, he could surpass Gibbs production but I would back him in 100% of Cotchin. Danger I am not touching since we don't know how the contract talks will do and he generally starts slow

[dmac07]

Parker vs Griffen. For score, not value. Only want keepers and rookies in the mids.

[Bully]

Parker vs Griffen. For score, not value. Only want keepers and rookies in the mids.

Parker's last 12 games have been at a 120 average, I would pick him based on that alone.

[Samsturmfels]

Beams (better Bye)  v Parker (more value)

[Keeper27]

Option 1.
Neale/Steven + $116k (105 x 2)

Or

Option 2.
Gazza/Newton + $91k (130 + 75)