Player X v Player Y

[Big Mac]

So would you pick Hamling or Goddard ?

Have the others in backs and Saad in forwards..

I'd only pick 3 of those boys so your only have one risky pick but even then some will only go with 2 rookies in defence and start Goodes at D6.

Saad from Saints is the fwd, Saad from GC is a def

Yeah sorry meant Saad in Mids.. sorry

ahh ok. Move him to your defence man. He's the best rookie available atm back there and there are better mid options

Yep there's plenty of other mid options

NVB, Newton, Cripps, CEM, VandenBerg, Heeney, Lambert, Cockatoo all solid picks

[Mark]

Will do, thanks guys

So aside from Higgins who is the best DEF/FWD?

McGovern, Frawley or Carlisle

[Nate93]

Rocky (M2) and Griffen (M5) vs JPK (M4) and Gray (M5)

Thoughts?

Also Parker vs JPK if I go with the second option.

Cheers

[heatedwire]

Forgive me if people have gone there, but what does everyone think about Sam Fisher.

He's been one of the all time fantasy guns, missed that much footy, but I feel his game could still hold up.

Thoughts?

[Bully]

Forgive me if people have gone there, but what does everyone think about Sam Fisher.

He's been one of the all time fantasy guns, missed that much footy, but I feel his game could still hold up.

Thoughts?

Too injury prone to consider, I think this is the year to pick durable defenders, Heath Shaw being the exception.

[Torpedo10]

Danger & Heater OR Fyfe + Newnes?

[Jackross10]

Danger & Heater OR Fyfe + Newnes?

Toughest choice I've seen, Danger and Shaw

[TexR74]

Rocky (M2) and Griffen (M5) vs JPK (M4) and Gray (M5)

Thoughts?

Also Parker vs JPK if I go with the second option.

Cheers

1st Option, although i would downgrade rockliff to someone like pendles/fyfe/selwood and use the extra cash elsewhere, very adventurous to go with both Rocky and Ablett

[TexR74]

DEF Oxley/RUC Maric vs DEF Goodes/ RUC Naitnui

[Torpedo10]

Danger & Heater OR Fyfe + Newnes?

Toughest choice I've seen, Danger and Shaw

Yeah it really had me stumped. I'm leaning towards the DangerShaw combo as you said, the way people are talking up Fyfe is scaring me though. Pendles, JSel, JPK & Griff are my other Mid premiums.

[Bully]

DEF Oxley/RUC Maric vs DEF Goodes/ RUC Naitnui

Option 2 easily.

[Torpedo10]

DEF Oxley/RUC Maric vs DEF Goodes/ RUC Naitnui

Definitely option 2.

[Nige]

Malceski + Newton vs Goodes + Steven

For context - the former gives me 6 premo defenders and 4 premo mids, the latter gives me 5 premo defenders and 5 premo mids.

The above is a part of my crazy but genius no GAJ plan.  8)

[Bully]

Malceski + Newton vs Goodes + Steven

For context - the former gives me 6 premo defenders and 4 premo mids, the latter gives me 5 premo defenders and 5 premo mids.

The above is a part of my crazy but genius no GAJ plan.  8)

Option 2, it gives you some chance of securing 2 keepers.

[Nige]

Malceski + Newton vs Goodes + Steven

For context - the former gives me 6 premo defenders and 4 premo mids, the latter gives me 5 premo defenders and 5 premo mids.

The above is a part of my crazy but genius no GAJ plan.  8)

Option 2, it gives you some chance of securing 2 keepers.

That's what I've gone with. The hope is that Eski drops in price (which is likely) and that I can potentially use Goodes to get him. Steven's scoring power for his price is what I value, considering he's basically a premo and if I'm not starting GAJ (who I intended to bring in ASAP), I'll need that.