Player X v Player Y

[bennyfraz]

B. SMITH VS GIBSON

FYFE VS PENDLES

NIC NAT VS MARIC

HELP

[RaisyDaisy]

B. SMITH VS GIBSON

FYFE VS PENDLES

NIC NAT VS MARIC

HELP

Flip a coin on all 3

If I had to pick though, Gibson, Pendles and NicNat

[barlowlove]

B. SMITH VS GIBSON

FYFE VS PENDLES

NIC NAT VS MARIC

HELP

Smith- Don't see enough love for him on this forum. Still young and improving, should average at least the same if he keeps the same role, or could increase his output with the talk of some midfield rotations.

Pendles- Coin flip, but a proven and consistent gun who doesn't miss games

Maric- NicNat is a better option if they were both fit and he is 50k cheaper, but I like Maric for his durability (which isn't amazing but its better than NicNat's) in a year where alot are going in with no ruck cover

[Ricochet]

B. SMITH VS GIBSON

FYFE VS PENDLES

NIC NAT VS MARIC

HELP

Smith- Don't see enough love for him on this forum. Still young and improving, should average at least the same if he keeps the same role, or could increase his output with the talk of some midfield rotations.

Pendles- Coin flip, but a proven and consistent gun who doesn't miss games

Maric- NicNat is a better option if they were both fit and he is 50k cheaper, but I like Maric for his durability (which isn't amazing but its better than NicNat's) in a year where alot are going in with no ruck cover

Apart from his debut year, NicNat has only had one year under 20 games

[barlowlove]

B. SMITH VS GIBSON

FYFE VS PENDLES

NIC NAT VS MARIC

HELP

Smith- Don't see enough love for him on this forum. Still young and improving, should average at least the same if he keeps the same role, or could increase his output with the talk of some midfield rotations.

Pendles- Coin flip, but a proven and consistent gun who doesn't miss games

Maric- NicNat is a better option if they were both fit and he is 50k cheaper, but I like Maric for his durability (which isn't amazing but its better than NicNat's) in a year where alot are going in with no ruck cover

Apart from his debut year, NicNat has only had one year under 20 games

Only played 11 games in 2013?

And has had ongoing groin issues throughout career as well as a back issue this preseason

[Ricochet]

B. SMITH VS GIBSON

FYFE VS PENDLES

NIC NAT VS MARIC

HELP

Smith- Don't see enough love for him on this forum. Still young and improving, should average at least the same if he keeps the same role, or could increase his output with the talk of some midfield rotations.

Pendles- Coin flip, but a proven and consistent gun who doesn't miss games

Maric- NicNat is a better option if they were both fit and he is 50k cheaper, but I like Maric for his durability (which isn't amazing but its better than NicNat's) in a year where alot are going in with no ruck cover

Apart from his debut year, NicNat has only had one year under 20 games

Only played 11 games in 2013?

And has had ongoing groin issues throughout career as well as a back issue this preseason

lol thats what I said

[barlowlove]

Apart from his debut year, NicNat has only had one year under 20 games

Only played 11 games in 2013?

And has had ongoing groin issues throughout career as well as a back issue this preseason

lol thats what I said

haha you're right sorry man

[Big Mac]

Not so much an X vs Y scenario, but taking out Simpson, Malceski and Shaw, who would be the next best defender?

I feel like there are so many options and I cant decide!

Hibberd > Hurn > Birch

[AFLWizard]

ibbo vs geary

[bottlemart]

ibbo vs geary

geary

Ablett and Steele v Swan and Titch

[Big Mac]

ibbo vs geary

geary

Ablett and Steele v Swan and Titch

<--------------

[Mark]

Ablett and anyone mate..

Rich in mids OR Ibbo/Geary in backline OR Salem forward plz guys...

[bottlemart]

ibbo vs geary

geary

Ablett and Steele v Swan and Titch

<--------------

To start ablett someone needs to go, cant fit em all in.

[H1bb3i2d]

Ablett and anyone mate..

Rich in mids OR Ibbo/Geary in backline OR Salem forward plz guys...

Such a vague question. Surely it would depend on who the other players involved were? Because you can't just replace one with the other.

[bottlemart]

Ablett and anyone mate..

Rich in mids OR Ibbo/Geary in backline OR Salem forward plz guys...

tough one, but Rich in mids.