Player X v Player Y

[Rusty00]

Newton vs Cripps

[Ricochet]

Newton vs Cripps

Newton. Just

[Nige]

Newton vs Cripps

For me, I think that you should have both. However, picking one is tough.

I'd probably go Newton. More of chance to play every game for Melbourne than Cripps is for Carlton you'd think.

[Rusty00]

Newton vs Cripps

For me, I think that you should have both. However, picking one is tough.

I'd probably go Newton. More of chance to play every game for Melbourne than Cripps is for Carlton you'd think.

Ideally I'd like to have both but at the moment I can't afford it :-\

[Nige]

Newton vs Cripps

For me, I think that you should have both. However, picking one is tough.

I'd probably go Newton. More of chance to play every game for Melbourne than Cripps is for Carlton you'd think.

Ideally I'd like to have both but at the moment I can't afford it :-\

What does the rest of the team look like, is there any way you can bring the other in?

[barlowlove]

What about Cripps vs NVB? Newton is locked for me, and I only have room for 2 200k+ rookies with Cockatoo also in my side at the moment

[Hawker_08]

Cockatoo and Griffen vs Cripps Ward

[shaker]

Think I would go Cripps NVB has not really impressed me so far

[Nige]

What about Cripps vs NVB? Newton is locked for me, and I only have room for 2 200k+ rookies with Cockatoo also in my side at the moment

I'd go Cripps. NVB may have JS on his side, but Cripps is the better option because he's slightly cheaper iirc and I think his ceiling is higher and NVB didn't look like he was going to meet our expectations which Cripps on the other hand probably will.

[Ricochet]

What about Cripps vs NVB? Newton is locked for me, and I only have room for 2 200k+ rookies with Cockatoo also in my side at the moment

NVB over Cripps for JS reasons. NVB will do exactly what you want him to do, play every game and make you cash

Cockatoo and Ward vs Cripps Ward

Ward and Cripps

[swans15]

Cockatoo and Ward vs Cripps Ward

So just Cockatoo vs Cripps? no need to put Ward in.
Hardly a comparison as there is a bit of a price difference. Cripps for sure out of the two.

[barlowlove]

Think I would go Cripps NVB has not really impressed me so far

I'd go Cripps. NVB may have JS on his side, but Cripps is the better option because he's slightly cheaper iirc and I think his ceiling is higher and NVB didn't look like he was going to meet our expectations which Cripps on the other hand probably will.

NVB over Cripps for JS reasons. NVB will do exactly what you want him to do, play every game and make you cash

Some interesting thoughts here have left me really torn, its lineball for me

[barlowlove]

Ward (or similar Premo) and Jacobs/Mummy

vs

NicNat and GAJ

*No ruck cover

[swans15]

Ward (or similar Premo) and Jacobs/Mummy

vs

NicNat and GAJ

*No ruck cover

Gaj and NicNat...GAJ is a lock.

[Nige]

Ward (or similar Premo) and Jacobs/Mummy

vs

NicNat and GAJ

*No ruck cover

If you're gonna pick Mummy, you'll need some form of ruck cover.

So the second option.