Player X v Player Y

[GoLions]

Barlow vs Parker

Barlow

[Fid]

Harry Taylor V Chris Yarran

[H1bb3i2d]

Barlow vs Parker

Barlow

JPK > Barlow > Parker

[H1bb3i2d]

Harry Taylor V Chris Yarran

Taylor

[Jackross10]

Barlow vs Parker

Barlow

JPK > Barlow > Parker

Yeah have had kennedy all preseason, this was for my M4 :)

[cortez]

Malceski + Salem or C Pearce + H Bennell?

[jfitty]

Malceski + Salem or C Pearce + H Bennell?

Malceski and Salem for sure

[SydneyRox]

Malceski + Salem or C Pearce + H Bennell?

Malceski and Salem for sure

100%

[TexR74]

Goddard vs Hannebery vs Macrae vs O'Meara vs Greene vs Cotchin vs Bennell vs Hartlett vs Tyson. Pick one (if you can)

[FactHunt]

Goddard vs Hannebery vs Macrae vs O'Meara vs Greene vs Cotchin vs Bennell vs Hartlett vs Tyson. Pick one (if you can)

Pretty tight there- I'm sure you'll get plenty of differing opinions for this group... here's how i see it:

Greene>Cotch>Hanners>Tyson>Bennell>Goddard>Macrae>Omeara>Hartlett for scoring, and not much in it across the board

But I like Goddard + Bennell for their flexibility, and I would look at taking one of them up forward over taking any of them in the middle.

[Ricochet]

Goddard vs Hannebery vs Macrae vs O'Meara vs Greene vs Cotchin vs Bennell vs Hartlett vs Tyson. Pick one (if you can)

Cotchin/Hannebery > Macrae/Greene/Goddard > Tyson/Bennell

O'Meara is injured
Hartlett is injured

[RaisyDaisy]

Not so much an X vs Y scenario, but taking out Simpson, Malceski and Shaw, who would be the next best defender?

I feel like there are so many options and I cant decide!

[GCSkiwi]

Not so much an X vs Y scenario, but taking out Simpson, Malceski and Shaw, who would be the next best defender?

I feel like there are so many options and I cant decide!

Flip a coin between any of them. With unlimited cash I reckon Burgoyne would be a safe bet but I don't see any upsie at his price tag over returning prem options like Birchall, or up and comers like Newnes. FWIW my D1-3 at the moment are Simpson, Heater and Birch, and I'm not even sold on Simpson.

[swans15]

Geary vs Sheppard

[Nige]

Sam Fisher v Lumumba

I've actually got both, but if I had to pick, I'd go Lumumba. I think he's just that bit safer.

Barlow vs Parker

Barlow

Faced that dilemma myself. Barlow's capable of scoring/averaging that bit more which is why I ultimately went him, but Parker is slightly cheaper and I think is a red hot chance of being company for Barlow.

Not so much an X vs Y scenario, but taking out Simpson, Malceski and Shaw, who would be the next best defender?

I feel like there are so many options and I cant decide!

It's a tough one. Honestly it could be anyone's guess. Maybe we need a thread to pick the top 5 in order for bragging rights and laughs at the end of the year.  ;)

Geary vs Sheppard

Geary. Ceiling is higher and is just generally a safer pick than somebody we've never really bothered to consider previously.