Player X v Player Y

Started by ben_020285, January 22, 2015, 01:00:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

honza

Quote from: Mat0369 on February 24, 2015, 11:02:59 PM
Quote from: meow meow on February 24, 2015, 10:53:28 PM
Deledio has been one of the most durable players of all time. Everyone is getting spooked about his chances of missing games due to an article mentioning him being sore. In the same article they mentioned that Dusty has a hamstring issue but that seems to go unnoticed. I wouldn't say one is more likely to miss than the other. The more games Martin plays, the closer he gets to one he's going to miss.

That same article said Lids had been carrying the injury for the last couple years and it is one that cause him to miss games last year. The fact it is not going away is a worry
The injury is a longer term one. It has flared up before but usually not in season. Last year it did. This was the comment from the club at the time.

No need to look too much in to this. If Deledio is named R1 he's fine.

smashbox

Which one would you choose?

Pendlebury is ever the consistent between 110-130 weekly.
Selwood always has a lean patch but goes bang when he scores big
Fyfe really became super elite last year, can he improve?

GoLions


Woppa15

I can't help you there sorry. I couldn't split them so have all three. Makes the bye Rnds look a bit precarious but I'm planning on having a few upgrades done by then.

Maybe Pendles comes out on top because of the 3 Fyfe and Selwood have been the ones thy seem to fluctuate in price more so may present a better chance for an upgrade opportunity down the track.

kilbluff1985


Big Mac


blue

Pendles easy, he will out score selwood and Fyfe will miss games somewhere along the line

Blues Blues Blues

Birchall (D3), Dangerfield (M5), Daniel (F8)

Vs

Ibbotson (D5), NVB (M5), Goddard (F1)

Basically:
- 5 premo defence (incl. newnes), 5  premo mids and 1 premo fwd plus Swan and Belly (14 keepers incl. Newnes)
OR
- 4 premo defence (incl. Newnes), 4 premo mids and 2 premo fwd plus Swan and Belly (13 keepers incl. Newnes)

Fwd line weak but other lines look horn...

:-\

Hagebear

Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on February 26, 2015, 06:25:09 AM
Birchall (D3), Dangerfield (M5), Daniel (F8)

Vs

Ibbotson (D5), NVB (M5), Goddard (F1)

Basically:
- 5 premo defence (incl. newnes), 5  premo mids and 1 premo fwd plus Swan and Belly (14 keepers incl. Newnes)
OR
- 4 premo defence (incl. Newnes), 4 premo mids and 2 premo fwd plus Swan and Belly (13 keepers incl. Newnes)

Fwd line weak but other lines look horn...

:-\

The second option for me. Can see NVB going close to Dangers average and can see Ibbo going close to Birchall (plus Birchall has a small injury at the moment)

honza

Quote from: Hagebear on February 26, 2015, 07:52:52 AM
Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on February 26, 2015, 06:25:09 AM
Birchall (D3), Dangerfield (M5), Daniel (F8)

Vs

Ibbotson (D5), NVB (M5), Goddard (F1)

Basically:
- 5 premo defence (incl. newnes), 5  premo mids and 1 premo fwd plus Swan and Belly (14 keepers incl. Newnes)
OR
- 4 premo defence (incl. Newnes), 4 premo mids and 2 premo fwd plus Swan and Belly (13 keepers incl. Newnes)

Fwd line weak but other lines look horn...

:-\

The second option for me. Can see NVB going close to Dangers average and can see Ibbo going close to Birchall (plus Birchall has a small injury at the moment)
NVB close to Dangerfield. maybe with the 350k i save i can have some of what you're smoking

Pkbaldy

Quote from: Hagebear on February 26, 2015, 07:52:52 AM
Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on February 26, 2015, 06:25:09 AM
Birchall (D3), Dangerfield (M5), Daniel (F8)

Vs

Ibbotson (D5), NVB (M5), Goddard (F1)

Basically:
- 5 premo defence (incl. newnes), 5  premo mids and 1 premo fwd plus Swan and Belly (14 keepers incl. Newnes)
OR
- 4 premo defence (incl. Newnes), 4 premo mids and 2 premo fwd plus Swan and Belly (13 keepers incl. Newnes)

Fwd line weak but other lines look horn...

:-\

The second option for me. Can see NVB going close to Dangers average and can see Ibbo going close to Birchall (plus Birchall has a small injury at the moment)

Vhuttttt? I'll be surprised if NVB gets within 15ppg to Danger... But Option 2 is still the better option.

Ricochet

Yeh NVB won't get anywhere near Danger.


honza


gook

Heritier Lumumba v Jack Newnes


bennyfraz

Danger & Treloar

Vs

Sidebottom & Cotchin

vs

Selwood & Brad Crouch