Player X v Player Y

[Mat0369]

If you trust his body, then Hurn easily.

I would have to agree with this. I think both are underpriced for what they are capable of this year and Lumumba has been more durable physically  but I can't see a hell of a lot between them if they both perform to what is expected of them

[Mat0369]

Rockliff v Fyfe

To start the year Fyfe but I think Rocky will have the better average come the end of the year. It is just I think Rockliff will drop further from his starting price then Fyfe will so you can pick up Rocky cheaper

[GoLions]

Rockliff v Fyfe

I probably shouldn't be answering this... :P

But for average, I'd say Rocky. Can't see him dropping by more than 5ppg. On value for money, it's a lot closer. Both copped a couple of suspensions last year, Fyfe slightly injury prone although don't think he missed any games due to injury last year? Think Rocky will pull his head in as captain now though, so I'd have him ahead of Fyfe still. Just.

You really can't go wrong with either though.

[nrich102]

Rockliff v Fyfe

I would also go Rocky.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :-\
Which 1 of these three would you consider taking,  H Taylor,  Lumumba,  or Docherty ??      ::)

[Ricochet]

:-\
Which 1 of these three would you consider taking,  H Taylor,  Lumumba,  or Docherty ??      ::)

Lumumba easily imo

[js19]

Going back and forth with these:

Goldy, Barlow, Gray

vs

Mummy, Pendles, Danger?

Any other combo? Guessing 1 will be more unique...

[eaglesman]

Yeo ... Will go 90 fraction of price

Why is everyone on a guy who has never scored 100 in the 40 games of his career? I know he has been promised midfield time but every club says that during pre season and some never do, Shaun Atley for example. Wouldn't touch him and can't see him going anywhere near 90, 75 is more realistic.

I think his username explains a fair bit.

LOL and yeah just about every player is getting their score predictions inflated on FF atm....apparently like 10 midfielders are going to go 120 this year!

Maybe it's my eagle bias :)

But at d5 even if he goes 80 I'll be happy

[johnnyy23]

LUKEEEY MCDONALD!

[MC]

Going back and forth with these:

Goldy, Barlow, Gray

vs

Mummy, Pendles, Danger?

Any other combo? Guessing 1 will be more unique...

Easy choice in my opinion. If anything i'd almost suggest Goldy/Pendles/Danger instead of Mummy, but it will probably be a coin-flip.

[My Chumps]

Going back and forth with these:

Goldy, Barlow, Gray

vs

Mummy, Pendles, Danger?

Any other combo? Guessing 1 will be more unique...

Definitely the second option, but I wouldn't recommend Danger.

Minson vs Nic Nat. Getting cold feet on the big Fijian recently.

[Ricochet]

Going back and forth with these:

Goldy, Barlow, Gray

vs

Mummy, Pendles, Danger?

Any other combo? Guessing 1 will be more unique...

Definitely the second option, but I wouldn't recommend Danger.

Minson vs Nic Nat. Getting cold feet on the big Fijian recently.

NicNat mate. Having his first real preseason in a long long time

[Mark]

If you trust his body, then Hurn easily.

I would have to agree with this. I think both are underpriced for what they are capable of this year and Lumumba has been more durable physically  but I can't see a hell of a lot between them if they both perform to what is expected of them

So with Lumumba being cheaper by $50,000 he would be the better pick yeah ??

[GoLions]

Going back and forth with these:

Goldy, Barlow, Gray

vs

Mummy, Pendles, Danger?

Any other combo? Guessing 1 will be more unique...

Easy choice in my opinion. If anything i'd almost suggest Goldy/Pendles/Danger instead of Mummy, but it will probably be a coin-flip.

Yeah I'd go Goldy/Pendles/Danger

[Grufflez]

Mummy has an insanely easy opening 5 rounds...could go huge, Goldy more durable.