Player X v Player Y

[MC]

Docherty v Lumumba
Seedsman v Kade Kool

Docherty & KK I reckon.

Seeds you'd have to watch closely in the NAB, too many variables with Taylor/Fasolo etc. He's almost definitely best 22, but KK is best 22 without any doubt, and will be pushing up the wing in 2015.

[hawkboy80]

Kade Simpson v Brodie Smith

Simpson's SC avg over the last 6 years: 95.5, 95.1, 94.1, 94.5, 99.8, 93.9

Easy choice there IMO

yeah runs on the board do it for me

[hawkboy80]

Look at Atley for movers to the mids. He's training with the mids and will be pushed up to a wing this year.

Isn't that said every year?

lol, the perennial break-out player!

I admit I did put him in my team for a day or so .....

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :)

Bontempelli  v  B Crouch.    Bont  to remain in team as for/mid reserve in the finals if all goes as planned
                                      B Crouch  more than likely be a stepping stone that scores pretty well along the way.
:-\

[eaglesman]

:)

Bontempelli  v  B Crouch.    Bont  to remain in team as for/mid reserve in the finals if all goes as planned
                                      B Crouch  more than likely be a stepping stone that scores pretty well along the way.
:-\

I'm considering going both
Bont up forward and crouch m6

[Sabretooth Tigers]

:)

Bontempelli  v  B Crouch.    Bont  to remain in team as for/mid reserve in the finals if all goes as planned
                                      B Crouch  more than likely be a stepping stone that scores pretty well along the way.
:-\

I'm considering going both
Bont up forward and crouch m6

:)

Just about have my final pre NAB team. It may come down between Crouch and Prestia in the midfield,  and  Bont and J Martin up forward.  Think I'll let the NAB Cup decide for me, now I can finally sit and wait hoping there are no more injuries. Cheers.  ;)

[eaglesman]

:)

Bontempelli  v  B Crouch.    Bont  to remain in team as for/mid reserve in the finals if all goes as planned
                                      B Crouch  more than likely be a stepping stone that scores pretty well along the way.
:-\

I'm considering going both
Bont up forward and crouch m6

:)

Just about have my final pre NAB team. It may come down between Crouch and Prestia in the midfield,  and  Bont and J Martin up forward.  Think I'll let the NAB Cup decide for me, now I can finally sit and wait hoping there are no more injuries. Cheers.  ;)

Think I would rather crouch / Bont

[eaglesman]

I structured up a new team and realised I didn't have swan in my forwards.

So it is
Martin vs Swan for F3

[Mark]

Pike or Luey

[nrich102]

Pike or Luey

Leuy by a long long way.

[H1bb3i2d]

I structured up a new team and realised I didn't have swan in my forwards.

So it is
Martin vs Swan for F3

Not a like for like, but Martin makes a better upgrade target..?

[Sabretooth Tigers]

I structured up a new team and realised I didn't have swan in my forwards.

So it is
Martin vs Swan for F3

Whoever gets more mid time in the NAB,  nah Martin by the length of the Flemington straight      ;)

[eaglesman]

I structured up a new team and realised I didn't have swan in my forwards.

So it is
Martin vs Swan for F3

Whoever gets more mid time in the NAB,  nah Martin by the length of the Flemington straight      ;)

70k massive price difference ... Can Martin outscore swan by an average of 13ppg to justify the selection

[AaronKirk]

I structured up a new team and realised I didn't have swan in my forwards.

So it is
Martin vs Swan for F3

Whoever gets more mid time in the NAB,  nah Martin by the length of the Flemington straight      ;)

70k massive price difference ... Can Martin outscore swan by an average of 13ppg to justify the selection

I would doubt it. I would predict both would average around the 100-105 mark come seasons end.

Clearly go the value with Swan and spend the extra 70k cash elsewhere.

[Mat0369]

70k massive price difference ... Can Martin outscore swan by an average of 13ppg to justify the selection

Martin should be a keeper and the question marks are still out on Swan

I am not Martin's biggest fan but I will say yes. I think Martin can improve his average by a couple of points while Swan might stay around the same average.