Player X v Player Y

[Jackross10]

Your loss imo Johnny, I see swanny going 110 at least this year. Last year was one to forget for him. Plagued with injuries while also fighting Glandular fever.

Swanny will be 31 before the season starts this year, I just don't see it happening. I haven't ruled him out entirely, but going him going above 110 is a ridiculous... Collingwood are in for a rough season. But let's make it interesting.

If by Rd 22 Swanny is averaging higher than 110, I will go to the Pies' last game dressed as an umpire and run onto the field during the 3rd quarter with a whistle and make as many calls as I can. Might even jump on with a footy and have a go from 50. Tell you what, in those few seconds alone, the security guards would lay more tackles than Swanny had all season and I'd kick just about as many goals ;)

Looking forward to seeing you tackled and copping a $8000 fine

[johnnyy23]

Your loss imo Johnny, I see swanny going 110 at least this year. Last year was one to forget for him. Plagued with injuries while also fighting Glandular fever.

Swanny will be 31 before the season starts this year, I just don't see it happening. I haven't ruled him out entirely, but going him going above 110 is a ridiculous... Collingwood are in for a rough season. But let's make it interesting.

If by Rd 22 Swanny is averaging higher than 110, I will go to the Pies' last game dressed as an umpire and run onto the field during the 3rd quarter with a whistle and make as many calls as I can. Might even jump on with a footy and have a go from 50. Tell you what, in those few seconds alone, the security guards would lay more tackles than Swanny had all season and I'd kick just about as many goals ;)

Looking forward to seeing you tackled and copping a $8000 fine

Look the truth of the matter is if he peaks in preseason I'll pick him up. But it's far more likely he will crash and burn somewhere between 90-100ish and others will score better. So I'll enjoy not getting tackled, sitting at home watching the Pies (and swan) have another below average year :)

[RaisyDaisy]

If by Rd 22 Swanny is averaging higher than 110, I will go to the Pies' last game dressed as an umpire and run onto the field during the 3rd quarter with a whistle and make as many calls as I can. Might even jump on with a footy and have a go from 50. Tell you what, in those few seconds alone, the security guards would lay more tackles than Swanny had all season and I'd kick just about as many goals ;)

This is gold!  ;D

[Blues Blues Blues]

If by Rd 22 Swanny is averaging higher than 110, I will go to the Pies' last game dressed as an umpire and run onto the field during the 3rd quarter with a whistle and make as many calls as I can. Might even jump on with a footy and have a go from 50. Tell you what, in those few seconds alone, the security guards would lay more tackles than Swanny had all season and I'd kick just about as many goals ;)

This is gold!  ;D

Agree, champagne comedy. Well played Johnny

[johnnyy23]

Cheers fellas (Y)

[eaglesman]

Ok lads 1 position to fix but it requires me to change 3 positions.

Which would you choose. Crunch the numbers

Ricky Henderson Brad Crouch Josh Kennedy

Vs

Brodie Smith Van Berlo Tom Rockliff

[Ricochet]

Ok lads 1 position to fix but it requires me to change 3 positions.

Which would you choose. Crunch the numbers

Ricky Henderson Brad Crouch Josh Kennedy

Vs

Brodie Smith Van Berlo Tom Rockliff

Safer, more cash generation, another captain option. Easily imo

[eaglesman]

Ok lads 1 position to fix but it requires me to change 3 positions.

Which would you choose. Crunch the numbers

Ricky Henderson Brad Crouch Josh Kennedy

Vs

Brodie Smith Van Berlo Tom Rockliff

Safer, more cash generation, another captain option. Easily imo

Henderson(75) crouch(105) kennedy(115) =295 points and profit of $149k

Vs

Vanberlo(75) rocky(125) smith (90) = 290 points and profit of 130k

How about now?

[Ricochet]

Ok lads 1 position to fix but it requires me to change 3 positions.

Which would you choose. Crunch the numbers

Ricky Henderson Brad Crouch Josh Kennedy

Vs

Brodie Smith Van Berlo Tom Rockliff

Safer, more cash generation, another captain option. Easily imo

Henderson(75) crouch(105) kennedy(115) =295 points and profit of $149k

Vs

Vanberlo(75) rocky(125) smith (90) = 290 points and profit of 130k

How about now?

I wouldn't include Crouch Kennedy Smith or Rocky in the cash generation because you will pick them as keepers.
So its Van Berlo vs Hendo only

[eaglesman]

Ok lads 1 position to fix but it requires me to change 3 positions.

Which would you choose. Crunch the numbers

Ricky Henderson Brad Crouch Josh Kennedy

Vs

Brodie Smith Van Berlo Tom Rockliff

Safer, more cash generation, another captain option. Easily imo

Henderson(75) crouch(105) kennedy(115) =295 points and profit of $149k

Vs

Vanberlo(75) rocky(125) smith (90) = 290 points and profit of 130k

How about now?

I wouldn't include Crouch Kennedy Smith or Rocky in the cash generation because you will pick them as keepers.
So its Van Berlo vs Hendo only

Probably a fair call but love to crunch numbers . Option b is also cheaper by 13k and would allow me to get Birchall to hibberd

However I would suggest Henderson has better job security than NVB,,, thoughts ?

[Ricochet]

Ok lads 1 position to fix but it requires me to change 3 positions.

Which would you choose. Crunch the numbers

Ricky Henderson Brad Crouch Josh Kennedy

Vs

Brodie Smith Van Berlo Tom Rockliff

Safer, more cash generation, another captain option. Easily imo

Henderson(75) crouch(105) kennedy(115) =295 points and profit of $149k

Vs

Vanberlo(75) rocky(125) smith (90) = 290 points and profit of 130k

How about now?

I wouldn't include Crouch Kennedy Smith or Rocky in the cash generation because you will pick them as keepers.
So its Van Berlo vs Hendo only

Probably a fair call but love to crunch numbers . Option b is also cheaper by 13k and would allow me to get Birchall to hibberd

However I would suggest Henderson has better job security than NVB,,, thoughts ?

I reckon both have question marks over them. Hendo scored well 2 years ago when Smith was still learning the ropes and Jaensch wasn't in the team. Now he's come back in and Smith is an AA rebounder, and Jaensch isn't far behind. Does that leave Hendo in a role that limits his scoring like 2014? Plus a new coach which could shake it up even further. I dunno, Hendo just has too much risk tied to him for me

[Holz]

Ok lads 1 position to fix but it requires me to change 3 positions.

Which would you choose. Crunch the numbers

Ricky Henderson Brad Crouch Josh Kennedy

Vs

Brodie Smith Van Berlo Tom Rockliff

Safer, more cash generation, another captain option. Easily imo

Henderson(75) crouch(105) kennedy(115) =295 points and profit of $149k

Vs

Vanberlo(75) rocky(125) smith (90) = 290 points and profit of 130k

How about now?

JPK NVB and the best defender you can afford is the best option.

[eaglesman]

Ok lads 1 position to fix but it requires me to change 3 positions.

Which would you choose. Crunch the numbers

Ricky Henderson Brad Crouch Josh Kennedy

Vs

Brodie Smith Van Berlo Tom Rockliff

Safer, more cash generation, another captain option. Easily imo

Henderson(75) crouch(105) kennedy(115) =295 points and profit of $149k

Vs

Vanberlo(75) rocky(125) smith (90) = 290 points and profit of 130k

How about now?

JPK NVB and the best defender you can afford is the best option.

Maybe more info needed

Shaw newnes Birchall Henderson waters whitecross (Goddard Mckenzie)
Ablett fyfe Kennedy Priddis crouch biggs heeney boekhorst (vandenberg freeman krakouer) $5400

Was what I had this morning (rucks and forwards are set)

Given this you would still suggest crouch to nvb Henderson to anyone(say smith) ... Leaving me 113k cash to splash on ???? Waters to Yeo perhaps

Like you Holz I feel wrong going against 5 starting keeper mids

[Big Mac]

Crouch + Simpson + Kreuzer + Bellchambers

Vs

NVB + Lumumba + Goldstein + Bennell

[Ricochet]

Crouch + Simpson + Kreuzer + Bellchambers

Vs

NVB + Lumumba + Goldstein + Bennell

Bottom one easily for me mate. Potentially 3 keepers