Player X v Player Y

[ben_020285]

Time for the 2015 edition.

[ben_020285]

Kade Simpson v Brodie Smith

[GoLions]

Kade Simpson v Brodie Smith

Simpson's SC avg over the last 6 years: 95.5, 95.1, 94.1, 94.5, 99.8, 93.9

Easy choice there IMO

[WizzFizz]

Ward v Sloane

[ben_020285]

Ward v Sloane

I prefer Ward. He is a star and captain of the club and contracted. I can see Ward averaging 120+ this year. Sloane is a gun but I am wary of his performance this year as there will be speculation as to whether he will remain at the Crows post 2015. Either way, I think Ward will average more than Sloane.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Ward v Sloane

I prefer Ward. He is a star and captain of the club and contracted. I can see Ward averaging 120+ this year. Sloane is a gun but I am wary of his performance this year as there will be speculation as to whether he will remain at the Crows post 2015. Either way, I think Ward will average more than Sloane.

As above.     ;)

How about  Hibberd v A Swallow  V B Crouch.  Can either have a mid + rookie   or   a defender +  rookie

[Jackross10]

Great thread. Walker vs Hurn

[ben_020285]

Ward v Sloane

I prefer Ward. He is a star and captain of the club and contracted. I can see Ward averaging 120+ this year. Sloane is a gun but I am wary of his performance this year as there will be speculation as to whether he will remain at the Crows post 2015. Either way, I think Ward will average more than Sloane.

As above.     ;)

How about  Hibberd v A Swallow  V B Crouch.  Can either have a mid + rookie   or   a defender +  rookie

Hibberd. I think he will be a keeper in defence but I doubt that A Swallow or B Crouch will average enough to be decent keepers in the midfield.

[ben_020285]

Great thread. Walker vs Hurn

Hurn for me. Walker has only had one decent year of scoring and his role at the Blues is a bit of an unknown. Hurn has had his injury worries but take out his one injury affected game from 2013 and his one injury affected game from 2014 and he has averaged 91.6, 94.7 and 91.4 over the last 3 years. I also expect him to stand up and lead by example as captain this year.

[T Dog]

Good work here gents.

Boomer v/s Dev Smith / Treloar ?

[Holz]

Good work here gents.

Boomer v/s Dev Smith / Treloar ?

Trealor, Boomer had abit of a spike and i expect him to drop a little with the support that was added. Devon Smith is good but just more proven forward options. Trealor wins by defualt but i would pick D. none of the above.

Jobe Watson - bad bye
v
Rory Sloane - good bye but pricy

[RaisyDaisy]

Jobe for mine holz, easily. His rd 12 bye is just one week. Price is too good to pass on

On the assumption that everyone is starting Deledio and Swan and has 1 or 2 forward spots left to fill

Goddard vs Buddy vs Dusty

[meow meow]

Kade

Sloane (neither)

Hibberd - no decent back rooks

Walker - Hurn isn't underpriced because he does the same thing every year, gets injured during a match and then you think you can pick him up cheaper than what he should score.

Treloar, not sure how you can compare fwds and mids though

Jobe, has upside and Sloane doesn't

Goddard. Bud will average more but always misses games.

[Holz]

Jobe for mine holz, easily. His rd 12 bye is just one week. Price is too good to pass on

On the assumption that everyone is starting Deledio and Swan and has 1 or 2 forward spots left to fill

Goddard vs Buddy vs Dusty

im not starting Deledio.

Buddy and Swan are the two locks.

[WizzFizz]

Jobe for mine holz, easily. His rd 12 bye is just one week. Price is too good to pass on

On the assumption that everyone is starting Deledio and Swan and has 1 or 2 forward spots left to fill

Goddard vs Buddy vs Dusty

Dusty plays 22 games every year, the other two always miss some games