Player X v Player Y

[ben_020285]

Yeah, why the images?  ???

Anyway, out of the four you mentioned I would only consider Bennell. I think he could easily average 100 this year and will average at least 95. Just needs to stay injury free to be a really good pick.

N Roo is getting too old and I think he will average less than 90 as the Saints look to other avenues up forward. Rioli will do a hammy at some stage so no point in picking him. Bundy needs to adjust to his new surroundings before he can be considered.

[Ringo]

Yeah, why the images?  ???

Anyway, out of the four you mentioned I would only consider Bennell. I think he could easily average 100 this year and will average at least 95. Just needs to stay injury free to be a really good pick.

N Roo is getting too old and I think he will average less than 90 as the Saints look to other avenues up forward. Rioli will do a hammy at some stage so no point in picking him. Bundy needs to adjust to his new surroundings before he can be considered.

Just a note on Bundy I have been to a couple of training sessions and since he has started full contact work he is fitting in very well and being well received by the team.  he is really enjoying himself out of the bubble and developing a very nice combo with Zorko and Green. Will play in NAB 3 next Friday night to observe for yourselves. Appears to be over the back issues but you can never tell with backs.

[hawkboy80]

Yeah, why the images?  ???

Anyway, out of the four you mentioned I would only consider Bennell. I think he could easily average 100 this year and will average at least 95. Just needs to stay injury free to be a really good pick.

N Roo is getting too old and I think he will average less than 90 as the Saints look to other avenues up forward. Rioli will do a hammy at some stage so no point in picking him. Bundy needs to adjust to his new surroundings before he can be considered.

I agree, Bennell of those 4 but won't be going there just yet

[Mark]

Karnezis or A.Saad ??? or neither ?? and stick with either Lonie or Lamb as F7-F8... Hmmmmm

[Capper]

one for the Weagles fans

Butler, Yeo or McGovern??

[Gigantor]

one for the Weagles fans

Butler, Yeo or McGovern??

Yeo, butler not guaranteed best 22 McGovern will play a lot in defense

[Mark]

Sorry I know its been done, but only 3 ppl commented....

Minson or Maric ???

Goldy vs Maric vs Minson

Goldy > Maric >>> Minson

this, but i really dont think the gap between Maric & Minnow isnt that big.

Yeah I agree, tossing up between Maric and Minson as R2 with NicNat's back issues worrying me, and leaning towards Minson

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :-[

Maybe just a little heavy in the midfield. Who would you omit out of Pendles,  Fyfe,  or J Selwood ??  Want to keep
Ablett, Ward,  and Prestia.  More than happy to run with all six, but           ::)

[GoLions]

:-[

Maybe just a little heavy in the midfield. Who would you omit out of Pendles,  Fyfe,  or J Selwood ??  Want to keep
Ablett, Ward,  and Prestia.  More than happy to run with all six, but           ::)

Drop Fyfe. Pendles is Pendles, Jelwood has the better bye and will probably be about equal with Fyfe on avg.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :)
Thanks GL    ;)

[Hoggyz_a_legend]

:-[

Maybe just a little heavy in the midfield. Who would you omit out of Pendles,  Fyfe,  or J Selwood ??  Want to keep
Ablett, Ward,  and Prestia.  More than happy to run with all six, but           ::)

Drop Fyfe. Pendles is Pendles, Jelwood has the better bye and will probably be about equal with Fyfe on avg.

This answered my next question- Pendles vs Fyfe. Pendles is mega consistent between 120-140 with a couple of 150+ thrown in. Fyfe seems to be more 100-160 to me. What would you rather? Both will avg 125-130 imo.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

:-[

Maybe just a little heavy in the midfield. Who would you omit out of Pendles,  Fyfe,  or J Selwood ??  Want to keep
Ablett, Ward,  and Prestia.  More than happy to run with all six, but           ::)

Drop Fyfe. Pendles is Pendles, Jelwood has the better bye and will probably be about equal with Fyfe on avg.

This answered my next question- Pendles vs Fyfe. Pendles is mega consistent between 120-140 with a couple of 150+ thrown in. Fyfe seems to be more 100-160 to me. What would you rather? Both will avg 125-130 imo.

Was the reply I was looking for too.       ;)

[My Chumps]

Pendles + Beams vs Ablett + Hannebery

[Keeper27]

Pendles + Beams

they'll avg much more over the year

[swans15]

Pendles + Beams vs Ablett + Hannebery

You should try and get both Ablett and Pendles