Player X v Player Y

[ben_020285]

Jobe for mine holz, easily. His rd 12 bye is just one week. Price is too good to pass on

On the assumption that everyone is starting Deledio and Swan and has 1 or 2 forward spots left to fill

Goddard vs Buddy vs Dusty

Goddard for me. I think Buddy will miss games through injury/suspension and I simply think Goddard will average more than Dusty.

[nrich102]

Krooz or Leuy?

[Vinny]

Kreuzer if he plays in the ruck during the NAB cup, Martin had a massive impact when playing so they are not going to cut him out, they'll have to adjust Leuy's role which leaves question marks. Whereas Warnock is clearly a spud, same goes for Wood, they showed they can't successfully fill the void when Kreuzer is missing. But gotta wait and see on him either way.

[RaisyDaisy]

Vinny, one of Warnock or Wood are going to play every week though aren't they? Surely Krooz isn't going to be left alone to do it all, especially coming off an LTI

Leuey over Krooz for me at this stage, but that can change - gotta wait for NAB

[Vinny]

I don't think they should RD but who knows what Mick will do. Kreuzer is so good as a sole ruckmen, he is not a forward. Have no idea why they try to make him one. Levi can give Kreuzer some help, but like I said gotta wait till NAB.

[Mat0369]

Vinny, one of Warnock or Wood are going to play every week though aren't they? Surely Krooz isn't going to be left alone to do it all, especially coming off an LTI

Leuey over Krooz for me at this stage, but that can change - gotta wait for NAB

Kreuz in the ruck, Levi up forward to give him a chop out. Kreuz has been training all pre-season and has shown in the past he has a good engine to be the solo ruck. You can't play either of the other spuds because they make the team worse. You also have Rowe who can pinch hit in the ruck. I would rather roll with Levi as the main ruck before going back to Tweedlespud and Tweedlespuddier

[quinny88]

Vinny, one of Warnock or Wood are going to play every week though aren't they? Surely Krooz isn't going to be left alone to do it all, especially coming off an LTI

Leuey over Krooz for me at this stage, but that can change - gotta wait for NAB

Kreuz in the ruck, Levi up forward to give him a chop out. Kreuz has been training all pre-season and has shown in the past he has a good engine to be the solo ruck. You can't play either of the other spuds because they make the team worse. You also have Rowe who can pinch hit in the ruck. I would rather roll with Levi as the main ruck before going back to Tweedlespud and Tweedlespuddier

Hasnt mick said krooz will be playing mostly forward though?

[Vinny]

Vinny, one of Warnock or Wood are going to play every week though aren't they? Surely Krooz isn't going to be left alone to do it all, especially coming off an LTI

Leuey over Krooz for me at this stage, but that can change - gotta wait for NAB

Kreuz in the ruck, Levi up forward to give him a chop out. Kreuz has been training all pre-season and has shown in the past he has a good engine to be the solo ruck. You can't play either of the other spuds because they make the team worse. You also have Rowe who can pinch hit in the ruck. I would rather roll with Levi as the main ruck before going back to Tweedlespud and Tweedlespuddier

Hasnt mick said krooz will be playing mostly forward though?

Mick can flower himself. :P

Nah, he didn't say that exactly man, he just said they want him to be more versatile, ''we want him to play a lot of ruck and forward'' not sure what that means, I won't be happy anyway if we do play him forward.

[quinny88]

Vinny, one of Warnock or Wood are going to play every week though aren't they? Surely Krooz isn't going to be left alone to do it all, especially coming off an LTI

Leuey over Krooz for me at this stage, but that can change - gotta wait for NAB

Kreuz in the ruck, Levi up forward to give him a chop out. Kreuz has been training all pre-season and has shown in the past he has a good engine to be the solo ruck. You can't play either of the other spuds because they make the team worse. You also have Rowe who can pinch hit in the ruck. I would rather roll with Levi as the main ruck before going back to Tweedlespud and Tweedlespuddier

Hasnt mick said krooz will be playing mostly forward though?

Mick can flower himself. :P

Nah, he didn't say that exactly man, he just said they want him to be more versatile, ''we want him to play a lot of ruck and forward'' not sure what that means, I won't be happy anyway if we do play him forward.

Haha is there a Carlton supporter out there that actually likes Mick?

Yeah I think it's stupid, he's a natural Ruckman that CAN rest forward, not a forward that can pinch hit in the ruck.

[ben_020285]

Krooz or Leuy?

I reckon this is very difficult to answer right now. I'm really hoping that NAB will show that one is the much better pick than the other.

Then we just have to pray that the one that looks the best doesn't get injured during the year or at least seriously injured.

Kreuzer, Leuey and Belly for that matter will be the 3 that I watch the closest during NAB.

[quinny88]

Lids v Goddard.

Hard to split. Both been 100+ for 7 years in a row. Both very durable

[ben_020285]

Lids v Goddard.

Hard to split. Both been 100+ for 7 years in a row. Both very durable

Very hard to split. In fact, I can't split them so the easiest choice for me is to just pick them both.

I guess if you have a lot of round 12 keepers then perhaps go with Deledio?

[quinny88]

Lids v Goddard.

Hard to split. Both been 100+ for 7 years in a row. Both very durable

Very hard to split. In fact, I can't split them so the easiest choice for me is to just pick them both.

I guess if you have a lot of round 12 keepers then perhaps go with Deledio?

Yeah I have both at the moment but have already conceded to the fact that I may have to only start one. Will wait and see though.
Yeah Deledio slightly more friendly to my bye structure I think so that may get him over the line

[Dayze]

lids has age on his side.
Goddard has an injury affected average.... Cant see why ud leave out either. Easiest decisions ive made this year

[Hoggyz_a_legend]

Brayshaw v Petracca