Player X v Player Y

[Fid]

Minson vs Naitnui, Nic Nat is a good cheap option, but I don't have cover in my forwards and my gut is telling me that Minson could have a really good year this year.

I've gone Minson, but in saying that they are both very good, thus similar in price.  I was encouraged with Minsons form in the NAB more so than Naitanui.

Both have upsides

Minson  - New coach and good NAB form - a chance to recapture his all australian form

Naitanui - No Cox and a chance to shine

[TexR74]

Minson vs Naitnui, Nic Nat is a good cheap option, but I don't have cover in my forwards and my gut is telling me that Minson could have a really good year this year.

I've gone Minson, but in saying that they are both very good, thus similar in price.  I was encouraged with Minsons form in the NAB more so than Naitanui.

Both have upsides

Minson  - New coach and good NAB form - a chance to recapture his all australian form

Naitanui - No Cox and a chance to shine

So
Goldstein vs Minson vs Naitnui (pick 2)

[Fid]

Minson vs Naitnui, Nic Nat is a good cheap option, but I don't have cover in my forwards and my gut is telling me that Minson could have a really good year this year.

I've gone Minson, but in saying that they are both very good, thus similar in price.  I was encouraged with Minsons form in the NAB more so than Naitanui.

Both have upsides

Minson  - New coach and good NAB form - a chance to recapture his all australian form

Naitanui - No Cox and a chance to shine

So
Goldstein vs Minson vs Naitnui (pick 2)

All good options

I have Goldy (R1) and Minson (R2)

[Mark]

Hibberd or Gibson...

Now Essendon are free to play will look hard at them..

[IntegralX]

Beams v Sloane v JPK (Pick 2)

Minsion v NicNat (No Belly as cover)

[Fid]

Beams v Sloane v JPK (Pick 2)

Minsion v NicNat (No Belly as cover)

JPK

Minson

NicNat still good regardless of cover imo

[Hawker_08]

TBC (R2) + Bennell (M3) + Vandenberg (M9) or Goldy (M1) + Hogan (F6) + Brayshaw (M6)

[Fid]

TBC + Bennell + Vandenberg or Goldy + Hogan + Brayshaw

2nd option imo

[_wato]

TBC 85, Bennell 100, Vandenberg 60 v Goldstein 110, Hogan 50, Brayshaw 75

First option based on points i think

[Hawker_08]

TBC 85, Bennell 100, Vandenberg 60 v Goldstein 110, Hogan 50, Brayshaw 75

First option based on points i think

What about on value. ie. money making

[_wato]

TBC 85, Bennell 100, Vandenberg 60 v Goldstein 110, Hogan 50, Brayshaw 75

First option based on points i think

What about on value. ie. money making

I'd say Option 2 if you were worried about money making mate.. Brayshaw will climb to $400k+ if he plays considering the raps on him, Hogan may be a slow burner and Goldy is a jet and you don't worry about any potential loss in cash
Bennell is a gun, and TBC will climb to $450kish at which point you could upgrade to a premium ruck, and Vandenberg is in a similiar position to Brayshaw.. If named could pocket you money but I'd say he'd max out at $300-350k

If Vandenberg is named I'd go with Option 1, if not you'd have to go option 2..
I'm guessing you already have Heeney/Anderson/Miller/Lambert too??

[Nathaneph]

KK and Rich vs Cripps and Gibson

[TomK]

KK and Rich vs Cripps and Gibson

Cripps and Gibbo

[Spite]

KK and Rich vs Cripps and Gibson

Cripps and Gibbo,


Belly + Rocky vs NicNat + Griffen
and also
Ibbo + Salem vs Tom mitchell + McIntosh (All fielded)

[blackrose]

KK and Rich vs Cripps and Gibson

Cripps and Gibbo,


Belly + Rocky vs NicNat + Griffen
and also
Ibbo + Salem vs Tom mitchell + McIntosh (All fielded)

Nicnat and Griff (2 potential keepers, can't see TBC being close to top ruck/fwd )

Ibbo and Salem (more $$ to be made)


For me, Beams + Dusty vs Gablett + Botempelli