Player X v Player Y

[Hawker_08]

I know this has been done before but Neale vs Steven. Pls keep in mind that I will be upgrading one of these to Ablett at around rd 6-7. Please also keep in mind their respective draws as I will want to pick the player that will make me the most for the Ablett upgrade. Steven - GWS, Gold Coast, Collingwood, Carlton, Essendon, Bulldogs and Adelaide
Neale - Port, Geelong, West Coast, Sydney, Melbourne, Essendon and Bulldogs
Cheers Lads

[RaisyDaisy]

I have one

Kieren Jack vs Daniel Hannebery

To be honest, neither. At their prices, you really need them to push Top 10, and I cant see them doing that

[RaisyDaisy]

I know this has been done before but Neale vs Steven. Pls keep in mind that I will be upgrading one of these to Ablett at around rd 6-7. Please also keep in mind their respective draws as I will want to pick the player that will make me the most for the Ablett upgrade. Steven - GWS, Gold Coast, Collingwood, Carlton, Essendon, Bulldogs and Adelaide
Neale - Port, Geelong, West Coast, Sydney, Melbourne, Essendon and Bulldogs
Cheers Lads

Probably Steven, because their run looks a little easier, and we don't know if Neale can keep scoring so well once the others (Barlow, Mundy etc) return, where as at least Steven does have some sort of history

[Mat0369]

To be honest, neither. At their prices, you really need them to push Top 10, and I cant see them doing that

One will go 110+ I am just trying to figure out which one and the other won't be far off

[Ricochet]

To be honest, neither. At their prices, you really need them to push Top 10, and I cant see them doing that

One will go 110+ I am just trying to figure out which one and the other won't be far off

Hannebery mate. This is the year to take the punt on him. Has killed his preseason and should explode early

[Mat0369]

Hannebery mate. This is the year to take the punt on him. Has killed his preseason and should explode early

I have had Hanners in all pre-season but I have been keeping my eye on Jack since he is also a star. I would start both but that would be overkill

[Ricochet]

Hannebery mate. This is the year to take the punt on him. Has killed his preseason and should explode early

I have had Hanners in all pre-season but I have been keeping my eye on Jack since he is also a star. I would start both but that would be overkill

Yeh can't go two. Like you i've just had that gut feeling on Hanners this year. All preseason they've talked up how much he's improved, I just can't pick him over Beams at the moment

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :-\
Who to keep out of Parker and Prestia  ??   ??      ???

[Mat0369]

If Gaz is named round 1 the meatball could be a handy pick. Both have a poor bye but Prestia wins so much ball and the attention would generally go to Gaz. From memory he struggled when Gaz got injured though so you would have to base the pick on Ablett's health

[roti]

Maric/Griffen vs Goldstein/Swallow

[Bully]

Maric/Griffen vs Goldstein/Swallow

Maric Griffen

[Money Shot]

Are both fit?
Will they play?
Who would you choose?

[Mark]

Sorry to be a little silly...But what Jones u talking about ??

[Ricochet]

ZJones?

Can't start either mate unless they somehow are named round 1 which I doubt

[Mark]

Yeah that's who I think he is talking about also but like you said Rico don't think either will play until Rd 3..

And if both named Rd1 for all supercoachers luck id take WhiteX

Cheers