i5s General Discussion

[Holz]

Israel

Hibberd
Dahlous
Mcevoy
Chapman
J.Gibson

No stars but could all go in the 90s.

pls mate, 4 stars. And the best punching defender in the game, and somehow is fantasy relevant. This team should go well.

It's solid but not how it will fare against teams with monsters scoring 150 some weeks.

That's when the draw or "luck of the draw" kicks in  ;)

Nek minute Macrae averages 80. BOOM!

[Holz]

Are we able to trade?

[Money Shot]

Are we able to trade?

[Big Mac]

Are we able to trade?

Also think will allow trading.... Every team needs to draft 16 players, but they can then trade however they want.

I.e.. trade 3 players for 1, doesn't matter if squad sizes aren't even

[tbagrocks]

Im not a fan of that at all! Not even in the slightest, takes all the skill from drafting wisely in the first place and just means that some stupid coaches will trade for young and spuds even though you can only keep three at the end of the year. SO YOU WONT BE ABLE TO KEEP THOSE FIRST ROUND DRAFT PICKS YOU HAVE as you will need to keep pretty much your three best meaning highest scoring players. Not those kids with big upside

Trades should be very carefully assessed

[Toga]

I'm all for trading though as it will make it a bit more exciting, get to have players from more than just the three origin teams!

[ADEZ]

Im not a fan of that at all! Not even in the slightest, takes all the skill from drafting wisely in the first place and just means that some stupid coaches will trade for young and spuds even though you can only keep three at the end of the year. SO YOU WONT BE ABLE TO KEEP THOSE FIRST ROUND DRAFT PICKS YOU HAVE as you will need to keep pretty much your three best meaning highest scoring players. Not those kids with big upside

Trades should be very carefully assessed

I agree, it came up earlier that it should be like for like eg. 1 for 1 or 2 for 2 and this would work, for example someone may have v. strong starting 3 but but their 5th is very average and another could have solid players across the park so somebody could trade a gun (100 odd) and a spud for a couple of solid players (80/85 odd)...
Also could give people to pick up smokeys that they rate highly but others do not

[LF]

You need to think of people from a weaker draft tho
Like the one with Port etc had no real premo mids  also with weaker depth in their draft.
It will give people the chance to trade to try and better their 5 or their depth.

[Pkbaldy]

If we are going to be trading it should be 1 for 1 or 2 for 2 and so forth... And have to be an even trade otherwise there are going to be strong teams that could just get even stronger and make it a boring game  :( I'd rather just not trade at all, just use the 16 players we got from the draft.

[LF]

If we are going to be trading it should be 1 for 1 or 2 for 2 and so forth... And have to be an even trade otherwise there are going to be strong teams that could just get even stronger and make it a boring game  :( I'd rather just not trade at all, just use the 16 players we got from the draft.

I agree should be 1 for 1 etc

But trading is part of the fun of these comps even tho sometimes it can be a little frustrating haha

[Holz]

If we are going to be trading it should be 1 for 1 or 2 for 2 and so forth... And have to be an even trade otherwise there are going to be strong teams that could just get even stronger and make it a boring game  :( I'd rather just not trade at all, just use the 16 players we got from the draft.

I agree should be 1 for 1 etc

But trading is part of the fun of these comps even tho sometimes it can be a little frustrating haha

Seems unnecessary 1 for 1.

Trading 2 good players for 1 star is a legit strategy. 2 for 2 just means spuds are added to deals.


On that note hibberd dahlous mcevoy all up for trade. Looking for a 2 for 1 deal. Hibbo and Dahlous both young and should score in the 90s

[ossie85]

No decision yet on trading yet

[T Dog]

Is trading open? or do we wait until all drafts finished?

[RaisyDaisy]

Trading has to be option. We all cant just have players from 3 teams - that would be boring

1-1 isn't necessary too. Perhaps we need a rule, say the minimum players you can have in your team is X and the maximum is X, that way someone wont do multiple 3 for 1 deals and just have a team of 7 super guns

Min 10 Max 20 or something like that?

[Pkbaldy]

If we are going to be trading it should be 1 for 1 or 2 for 2 and so forth... And have to be an even trade otherwise there are going to be strong teams that could just get even stronger and make it a boring game  :( I'd rather just not trade at all, just use the 16 players we got from the draft.

I agree should be 1 for 1 etc

But trading is part of the fun of these comps even tho sometimes it can be a little frustrating haha

Seems unnecessary 1 for 1.

Trading 2 good players for 1 star is a legit strategy. 2 for 2 just means spuds are added to deals.


On that note hibberd dahlous mcevoy all up for trade. Looking for a 2 for 1 deal. Hibbo and Dahlous both young and should score in the 90s

Why is it unnecessary? Some teams have 20 players and others have 10 by trading 2 for 1. Yeah seems fun to me.