Simple question?

[Dale S]

Ok looking at downgrading either Joel Selwood or Brent Stanton to Miles?

Who would you trade and why?

Current Midfield Ablett, Pendles, Swan, Stevie J, Redden and Cotchin

[jvalles69]

I haven't actually paid much attention to Stanton this year so can't comment, but I traded Jelwood out this week for Boomer Harvey to swing him into my fwds, I gave Jelwood a few weeks to change my mind, he was on track last week and then slowed down so I've booted him.

[d.clohesy]

Both having up and down weeks. Not top line premos i dont think

[Dave085]

Personally I wouldnt trade either unless it is to Barlow/Rocky/Beams etc. unless it is going to help you upgrade somewhere else. Even then, are you going to carry Miles for the rest of the season?

Im a bit annoyed I missed Greenwood. I was very close to trading him in for Polec. I just had enough for Barlow and thought I might as well go premo rather than a gamble. Its not always going to work like that though so I reckon youre better off holding them for now and upgrading to in form premos later on.

[Thunderbolts]

I've actually done something similar - did Monty to Miles and took the cash. I think he will 3 figure up against the saints...

Cash I'll use next week on shenton to premo since the bank is now 400k+

[HBTD22]

I haven't actually paid much attention to Stanton this year so can't comment, but I traded Jelwood out this week for Boomer Harvey to swing him into my fwds, I gave Jelwood a few weeks to change my mind, he was on track last week and then slowed down so I've booted him.

Ouch.

[Dale S]

Well I ended up keeping them both and you never guess who I brought in? Paul Chapman. FMDT 2014

[jvalles69]

I haven't actually paid much attention to Stanton this year so can't comment, but I traded Jelwood out this week for Boomer Harvey to swing him into my fwds, I gave Jelwood a few weeks to change my mind, he was on track last week and then slowed down so I've booted him.

Ouch.

When I saw his score last night was pissed and thought that he might do that, but it let me bring in a top fwd in Harvey instead of taking McGovern's (unless he goes massive this week) and lets me play Miles on the field for the next two weeks at least and then have the option of picking who I want a my final mid.  Thats DT for ya.

[jvalles69]

What chaos, I trade Jelwod to Boomer instead of Nroo to Boomer and play Wingard on field with Dahlhaus on the pine...my worst week by far this season and lost a league match to a mate who I've never lost a matchup too in 6 years to boot! :(