Trade option 1 or 2?

[Hearts2Hearts]

So far I'm sold on downgrading Fasalo to Shenton and swinging him to my mids so I can loophole both mid and fwd rookies. That leaves me with $256k for an upgrade.

Def - Bartel, Simpson, McVeigh, Hibberd, Swallow, Langdon (Bews/Clurey)

Mid - GAJ, Pendles, Beams, Jelwood, Fyfe, Libba, NDS, Hallahan (Acres/Shenton)

Ruck - Sandi, Lobbe (Currie/Thurlow)

Fwd - Danger, Martin, Roughy, Zorko, Higgins, Cameron (McDonough/Honeychurch)

Option 1 = Hallahan > Goddard
Option 2 = Higgins > Parker/Gray

Leaning towards option 2 as Hallahan still has some good money to make.

Thoughts?

[kilbluff1985]

getting that M8 premo now is really important but i wouldn't like play 2 fwd rookies

and have you considered Barlow? is more of a bargain then Goddard imo

[Hearts2Hearts]

Do you mean its worring having rookies at F6 and F7? I thought only having one rookie on the field in my forwards wasn't too bad.

Didn't even think of Barlow so have given me another think to think about! How much is he atm?

[kilbluff1985]

Do you mean its worring having rookies at F6 and F7? I thought only having one rookie on the field in my forwards wasn't too bad.

Didn't even think of Barlow so have given me another think to think about! How much is he atm?

Barlow is 536k looked good just before the bye after returning from injury

you have to sub Shenton for Higgins don't you? so you have to play 2 of Shenton, Cameron, McDon or Honey

[ants]

Do you mean its worring having rookies at F6 and F7? I thought only having one rookie on the field in my forwards wasn't too bad.

Didn't even think of Barlow so have given me another think to think about! How much is he atm?

Barlow is 536k looked good just before the bye after returning from injury

you have to sub Shenton for Higgins don't you? so you have to play 2 of Shenton, Cameron, McDon or Honey

Do you mean its worring having rookies at F6 and F7? I thought only having one rookie on the field in my forwards wasn't too bad.

Didn't even think of Barlow so have given me another think to think about! How much is he atm?

Barlow is 536k looked good just before the bye after returning from injury

you have to sub Shenton for Higgins don't you? so you have to play 2 of Shenton, Cameron, McDon or Honey

he has already done it with honeychurch!