The Prime Team!!

Started by Yoda, March 11, 2010, 01:58:57 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

rate my team

4/10 or less
0 (0%)
5/10
0 (0%)
6/10
2 (66.7%)
7/10
0 (0%)
8/10
1 (33.3%)
9/10
0 (0%)
10/10
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Yoda

. Heys guys just wondering if i could get some thoughts on my team cheers

Goddard, Hurn,Gilbee,Hodge,malceski, hunt,Waters.
  (Schimit?, maguire
 
Montagna,Selwood, Boyd,Mcveigh,Walker, Martin, ( Banner, Barlow)
 
Tippett ,Nic nat, (Lobbe, j roughead)
 
Riewoldt, O'Keefe, Higgins, Brown, Hall,, Mayne, Medhurst, (Stewart
  Podsiadly)
 

billy1000

Your rucks need a serious overhaul Hille and Skipper aren't good enough.

Even if you think Hiller is a lock i personally don't think Skipper is good enough. You need to find some money somewhere to upgrade Skipper to at least a Seaby.

The Grundles

ouch...some bad moves here...

starting with hille and skipper in ruck? you need to upgrade here...also Stanley as your 4th will play probably the least of the rookie rucks this season...try j roughead instead.

Boyd is a good unique but Barlow hasn't even earned an elevation yet so a risky spot for a starter.

B... is that Brown? or Buddy? Mayne is a talent but doesn't find enough of the ball for my liking.

Keep working champ

Yoda

Quote from: billy1000 on March 11, 2010, 02:02:42 PM
Your rucks need a serious overhaul Hille and Skipper aren't good enough.

Even if you think Hiller is a lock i personally don't think Skipper is good enough. You need to find some money somewhere to upgrade Skipper to at least a Seaby.

No worries thanks mate ill see how i go cheers

Yoda

Done some trades, I think it's more balanced now.. What does everyone think?

mjpaps

Waite could be risky as he hasnt played much at all.
Im waiting to see if Moles gets elevated from the rookie list.
Personally id trade Petrie for Jolly

Overall, fairly well balanced side...
8.5 / 10
please rate mine
:P

Cicjose

i dont think that having skipper on your bench is a bad thing cause he's likely to become no.1 ruck for the hawks with Taylor going down. Clarkson picked up skipper for a reason so he's likely to get a start with renouf

Ryder30

Mm that's actually a pretty good team, salopek is a interesting pick but it could very well be a good well.
Probab

CFC 1979

your the only team i have seen that has the guts to put petrie in ( even though susp rnd 1) He will carve it up this year

CFC 1979

sorry Yoda forgot to vote

The force is not with me to-night :D

Yoda

Have done alot of new things to this team and reset the poll so leave some feedback now please. :) Thanks

Prospector_1

Aaaaahhhh, young sandgroper, a 5 to 6 means you are trying, but not doing!

Yoda

that was my old team i hadnt reset the poll yet

Prospector_1

Thinking of voting the 9/101, but that would be v. low...