Need HELP! will comment on your team 2!

Started by steve_maxwell23, March 15, 2010, 03:01:31 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Is this team any good?

1
3 (15%)
2
3 (15%)
3
3 (15%)
4
3 (15%)
5
3 (15%)
6
3 (15%)
7
4 (20%)
8
4 (20%)
9
3 (15%)
10
3 (15%)

Total Members Voted: 20

steve_maxwell23

Have got $312,200 still to burn and was wondering what u rate my team and comment on where i can spend the cash. My main problem is the backline(not very strong atm), so i most likely spend it there. still tryin to see if i can fit riewoldt in frwd line.

Any opinions on any part of my team would be great and i'll comment on your team if u like! Cheers

Backs:

S.Fisher
L.Hodge
J.Gram
N.Krakouer
N.Malcheski
J.Hunt
B.Waters
emg:
B.Sheppard
M.Maguire

Mids:
G.Ablett
S.Mitchell
A.Cooney
L.Ball
J.Trengove
D.Martin
emg:
M.Barlow
B.Moles(or maybe bastinac)

Rucks:
H.McIntosh
Nic Nat
emg:
W.Skipper
J.Trengove

Forwards:
ROK
S.Johnson
L.Franklin
Gia
B.Hall
P.Dangerfield
J.Ziebell
EMG:
T.Rockliff
J.Podsiadly(thinkin of gettin gumbleton or hitchcock instead)

reesbr

get rid of Krakouer
S.johnson fo pav
upgrade nic nat to someone like ryder or tippett
7/10
please rate mine :)

c4v3m4n

As it stands:

Backs - Yeah, its a little weak. Your really missing one more premium player.

Mids - Personally, I dont like Cooney. Worst player to win the brownlow. Ablett should have won it in 2008. Or even Richo  ;D

Rucks - No problems there.

Forward - Nice but yeah, Riewoldt would cement the line up.

So in conclusion, use the money to upgrade one backline player to a premium, upgrade HMac to Clark/Sandi, upgrade S.Johnson to Riewoldt. If you have any left over, maybe a bit more in the backline...

Good luck and happy supercoaching!  :D

PS. I'd love to hear your thoughts on my team. Thanks.
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,9354.msg58942.html#msg58942

Nick_1069

backline is risky, krakour should be out and gram is debatable. 6/10

mids are very solid. 9/10

rucks are good, maybe downgrade nic nat to seaby and get sandi? 9/10

fowrads very even, but stevie j just dosent do it for me. pav, brown are other options. 8/10

overall, solid team 8/10.

check out mine please!

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,9503.0.html



supercoachheroes

i think krakeour and gram are fine. maybe upgrade karkeour to enright or duffield then it would be looking very good. steve j to riewold for sure. after this very good team.

steve_maxwell23

Quote from: Nick_1069 on March 15, 2010, 03:16:12 AM
backline is risky, krakour should be out and gram is debatable. 6/10

mids are very solid. 9/10

rucks are good, maybe downgrade nic nat to seaby and get sandi? 9/10

fowrads very even, but stevie j just dosent do it for me. pav, brown are other options. 8/10

overall, solid team 8/10.

check out mine please!

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,9503.0.html


cheers mate, only thing i would disagree with is IMO i think gram will have a big year so i'm taking a big risk with him, hoping it pays off! i'm thinkin of keeping b.waters as apprently he played a really good game and he will rise in value, would u agree or not?

steve_maxwell23

Quote from: supercoachheroes on March 15, 2010, 03:46:19 AM
i think krakeour and gram are fine. maybe upgrade karkeour to enright or duffield then it would be looking very good. steve j to riewold for sure. after this very good team.

Cheers mate but i think they are looking for krakeour to play a more defensive role this year so i might get rid of him. Yeah i think gram will do well this year. I've been looking at your teams you've been posting recently mate and its looking very good. Overall where did u finish last year and post the link to ur lastet team on here mate and i'll comment, cheers!

salce

waters is a risk...yeah ive heard his preseason has been good, yet he has never played a full season of footy - try and upgrade

try and get sanidlands in ruck, i know macintosh is a great buy but sandilands will dominate this year

riewoldt is a must, upgrade stevie j to him

overall 8/10

check mine out: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,9490.0.html