Which 3 rookies / cheapies to start?

Started by tor01doc, April 15, 2014, 11:06:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

tor01doc

Please pick 3.

Vest wearers will not start on my field!

I have swung Taylor to mids to add DPP and make room for Fasolo.

Judd Magic

#1
I have this problem too mate

Currently have to decide which 2 out of Dunstan, Kelly, Crouch and Ellis to start.

Think I'm leaning to Ellis and Crouch as Dunstan wont get much of the ball due to Essendons high possession keeping game.

To answer your question I would go with Polec, Crouch and Ellis.

Crouch is playing GWS and Ellis should score better than last week playing back at Perth with a few more West Coast ins this week.


kilbluff1985

Polec and Crouch obvious

coin flip between Ellis and Dunny

i'd go Ellis

AaronKirk

Quote from: kilbluff1985 on April 15, 2014, 11:10:05 PM
Polec and Crouch obvious

coin flip between Ellis and Dunny

i'd go Ellis
Agree with KB

Bully

Polec, Crouch & Ellis for me. Dunstan looks to be on the wane, I may even consider trading him to Robertson as early as next week, will just have to wait and see how both players go.

fever


fever

if flipping a coin between ellis and dunstan surely it's gotta land on the one that has a 140 in him

Typhnn

Quote from: fever on April 16, 2014, 12:28:28 AM
if flipping a coin between ellis and dunstan surely it's gotta land on the one that has a 140 in him

With J.Steven back in the mids as well now, and st. kilda playing the Bombers can you see him scoring well??  I'm predicting around 70...!!


HotTiges

Had a negative role on Danger but DE seemed down.. Like a lot of Saints.. Will be watching and hoping he can get to byes

Ringo

Polec for certain and then Crouch the remaining 3 imo will probably all average around 70 so toss a coin.

Ricochet

Reckon you gotta go Dunstan over Ellis. Purely because of his ceiling.
Ellis has gone 60-100 so far this year
Dunstan 50-140

Don't think Ellis will go much bigger than Dunstan on a good day but Dunstan could go 50+ on Ellis on a good day.