Buckley now or wait for Crouch?

[Rusty00]

Looking to offload Michie for one of these two. I was impressed with Buckley in his first game against Richmond but it was hard to get a good gauge against Essendon because Carlton as a team were rubbish. Crouch maybe has slightly better JS given some injuries to Adelaide's midfield.

Thoughts?

[TomK]

Wait for Crouch.

[nrich102]

Id wait for Crouch, but if you were to want to get someone whos price changes this week, you could get Kade Kolo if you have a mid/back dpp.

[Dudge]

Hard call mate right now. If Crouch avoids the vest, I'd say him. Seems to find the ball with ease, but his efficiency needs some fine tuning. Wait for Crouch

[fidou]

Ive been impressed by Buckley and would love to get him in. Crouch seems to be the better long term option but if you want a POD Buckley would be good.

[RoughRed]

crouch for me
had on bench early and will hold
believe the genetics will hold true :)

[Mr.Craig]

I don't trust Carlton players as far as I could throw them and Buckley's face reminds me of one of those troll dolls from the 90's. For all those reasons and more I'd wait for Crouch.

[henry]

I've gone Kelly as a unique, get on him he's a gun!

[Slammer]

Buckley gets my vote. Gonna bring him in myself. Mick loves him and he knows how to find the ball.
I would draw a line through his game against Essendon. No player scored well and he was always under pressure.

[essendon2]

Sam Gray 98k ;)

[Rusty00]

Sam Gray 98k ;)

Personally I'm not convinced with Gray's JS. Only got a game due to injuries.

I ended up going Michie to Buckley. Not too worried about the low score given he's M10.

[Ricochet]

Yeh I'm a bit worried that Gray might come out for Wingard or Monfries. Although he was bloody good on the wkend