Hibberd vs Hurn vs ?

[diamw90]

Beat option with a mcveigh, Mitchell, Enright ?, suckling, McDonald

$570k bank...

[GoLions]

In this order: Hurn, Hodge, Hanley, Thompson, Hibberd

FWIW I would've taken Simpson over all these guys

[diamw90]

Something about hibberds pod status...

[GoLions]

Something about hibberds pod status...

Apart from Hanley (and I guess Hodge) they're all PODs

Hurn - 4.47%
Hodge - 11.95%
Hanley - 23.10%
Thompson - 3.35%
Hibberd - 3.11%

Would also suggest Birchall who is owned by 6.08%

Obviously Hibberd is the least owned here, but I doubt he'll outscore any of these guys. Perhaps Hurn, but Hurn is way underpriced due to one of his games last year where he got injured and subbed off on 8 points.

[juzztheball]

In this order: Hurn, Hodge, Hanley, Thompson, Hibberd

FWIW I would've taken Simpson over all these guys

Can i ask what turns you off Hibbo? i chose him over all the options youve mentioned. Good long kick, efficient, and gets alot of ball. Dodgy hamstring but if fit surely hes just as good an option if not better than the others named??

[GoLions]

In this order: Hurn, Hodge, Hanley, Thompson, Hibberd

FWIW I would've taken Simpson over all these guys

Can i ask what turns you off Hibbo? i chose him over all the options youve mentioned. Good long kick, efficient, and gets alot of ball. Dodgy hamstring but if fit surely hes just as good an option if not better than the others named??

Don't get me wrong, he's a good scorer, very consistent. But of those guys I mentioned;
Hurn is amazing value, averaged like 95 unsubbed last year so is severely underpriced and should be a keeper
Hodge I think can push for a 100 average
Hanley I think will average 95-100
Thompson I only place above Hibberd due to his injury concern, think they'll average about the same though (95-ish)
And Birchall I think will average 95-100 and is a tad underpriced due to getting subbed off injured last year (would place him equal with Hanley actually)

[maygs]

Hanley.

Hibberd and Hanley are likely keepers.  Hurn is a possible smalll cash cow with reasonable score (80+). 

What does your team need?  More cash/more trades or more Premiums/more flexibility?

[GoLions]

Hanley.

Hibberd and Hanley are likely keepers.  Hurn is a possible smalll cash cow with reasonable score (80+). 

What does your team need?  More cash/more trades or more Premiums/more flexibility?

Please tell me you're joking about Hurn...

[Bully]

Hanley.

Hibberd and Hanley are likely keepers.  Hurn is a possible smalll cash cow with reasonable score (80+). 

What does your team need?  More cash/more trades or more Premiums/more flexibility?

Please tell me you're joking about Hurn...

I hope he's joking, strange comment indeed. Excluding his subbed game he scored under 80 twice in 11 games, with 5 tons and a 99.