Mid rookies

Started by LaHug, March 20, 2014, 07:28:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

LaHug

Also posted this in DT P&T but good to get some discussion from both sides of the game...

With Crouch not named (not really surprising but I was hopeful), there's a spot left on many of our mid benches.

The following is the list of all mid "rookies" playing this weekend:
Tyson, Michie, Billings (fwd), Aish, McDonald (def), Ellis, Dunstan, Templeton, Bennell, Gleeson, Taylor (fwd), Wanganeen.

I already have Tyson, Michie, Dunstan and I need to pick one more for the bench spot...

Who here has decent JS? Who will score well? Who will make the most money?

Aaaaaaaaaaaand discuss!

LaHug

The other option is to move McDonald (currently on my field in defence) to the mid bench and put Jayden Hunt (mid/def) on the field in the backs. This means I'd get Langdon's 111 in exchange for having a non-playing rookie that I could switch between mids and backs. Probably not worth the loss in cash-cowing though.

GCSkiwi

Ellis or Aish - I think Ellis will be better but plenty of concerns about his durability, if it scares you too much then grab Aish. Taylor may also replace JKH on my fwd bench if he is not the sub - looking at the Melb bench it's hard to see Georgiou Michie or Jones getting the vest... Think it really has to be between Georgiou or JKH in that line up and think Georgiou has probably earned a starting spot...

Definitely would not go dow a cash cow just for a score for one week, that's silly business!

GoLions

Ellis > Aish >>>>> Everyone else

LaHug

Cheers guys. That was my thought too. Wasn't sure who to grab out of Ellis and Aish and still not clear now. But at least we've confirmed that they're the two.