rate my and ill rate yours

[milnesmarvels]

b: Goodard   Bock   Enright   Hargrave   Hodge   Ladson    Hunt
res: Waters   Maguire

M:  Ablett(c)   Selwood   Mcveigh  Martin   Barlow  Banner
res: Shuey   Moles

R: Hille   White/NicNat
Res: Warnock   Lobbe

F:  Chapman   Reiwoldt   Harvey   Sylvia   Higgins  Hall  Wright
Res:   Rockliff  Podseildy

8,700k left

[Ricko]

Not a bad looking team mate, Bock ladson and hunt could be a deadly combo for your backline, big risk imo. Hille also is a worry, will he come back from injury well or not ? Other than the injury risk's good looking team 8/10

[spike#12]

pretty strong team, the backline part but hey you gotta take risks, im a fan of hille, hope he has a cracker season. not certain on banner, will he play? dnt think port have and rookie elevation spots, rodan comes back soon, id say moles, as he will be likely to get the dogs elevation and seemed to doo alright. 8/10 good job.

[Rowan1812]

Hille wont be any good for weeks as he hasnt had much of a preseason. Need a good ruck and then nat will be fine. 3 rookies in mid is too risky. Silvia not consistent enough. has too many low scores. Please comment on my team. Just posted

[milnesmarvels]

Ricko: who do u think for bock, Gilbert? or Shaw? and it is either ladson hunt or malskki. 2 of those 3.  Yer hill is a risk but thats wots SC is about. cheers for the feedback

Spike:yer the 5 rookies in the mids should be able to cover each other im predicting, thxz for cmmenting

Rowan: Im happy to upgrade hill later in the season at the moment but gotta see how he goes and see will summ up his nab cup at the end of this week, yer silvia im not sure abot but need to be a bit different nad i felt last year hes about to burst, i cant find ur team post it on this post and i can rate it. cheers

[tomsully]

does the job, backline a little weak,. im not to sure about chapman because his injury prone and old. and very pricey. better off with pavlich and upgrading a back to a kennelly or a xav ellis.

[Kazahkstan]

I don't think the backline is weak. Everyone up to Hodge is consistent.
Just because Chapman is old-ish, doesn't mean he won't perform. Sure, he's slightly injury-prone, but when he's not injured, he is one of the best players in the league.

Which McVeigh is that in the midfield, by the way?

[mjpaps]

Not too shabby at all...
Just a few ideas of mine for you to consider.

Would trade Bock for Heater, in a heartbeat. Heath looks primed.  ;)
Still questions over Bock. As reliable as he may be.
Hunt for Malceski.
I like Hargrave btw.
KEEP Banner he's a gun.
I do you think you need to upgrade Hille for someone who will def play 22 eg Jolly.
However that still could be a risk worth taking.
I would take Nic Nat over White.
Chappy for me is a bit injury prone. Sorry to say I dont rate Sylvia that highly.
Would probly trade them for Pav & J.Brown.
5 rookie kids in the mid is a HUGE risk. If it pays off you'll be laughing aye.
I spose we're all waiting to see the rookie elevations, as u have 3.
Moles / Barlow / Pods.

Overall I have to say it looks quite solid...Nice1
8 / 10

PLEASE rate mine

[milnesmarvels]

mjpaps:yer ive been keen on changing to shaw, yer i forgot to updadte that i put malckeski in for hunt, hargrave i dont think many know about, hes alot like boyd

Kazakatan: i agree totally with u on chapman had him alst year and for the games he wsa out he made up with the games of 160 he was in. thats mark from essondon, i know hes out for the first game but i need to be dif and i dont know many other on him espically at his proce he may be old but im sure he can sure get a bit of the pill with stanton and watson taking tags before him