Terlich or Simpson

[Braxtonators]

Need to know by tonights game - I have Simpson in my team at the moment, but have been thinking about Terlich and really want him in my team, and I am starting to question Simpson.

Terlich with a new coach, playing higher possession footy, still gonna tackle everything and he was great in a crap team last year. 

Thoughts?

[Ricochet]

Simpson easily. More proven and consistently pumps out premo averages. Also with Judd and Carrots out he will have to step up through the mids

[Braxtonators]

Good point Rico - forgot about those guys.

Thanks for all the votes - will stick with my 1st decision - Kade don't let me down

[DT Gun]

do you stick with kade now walker is almost certain to miss weeks?

Think he will get reported for 2 stupid things he did

[Smileys Bruisres]

After what i seen lastnight i don't rate Carlton at all this year. Terlich with the new game plan could rack up plenty of +6's. might be a swap for round 2.

[callum111]

I think terlich will get soooooo many mark and kick (+6) combos out of the back pocket this year with paul roos possession football I'd be surprised to see him avg less than 90.

The only issue being the fact melbourne sucked last year

[R.Griffen]

Terlich is not a proven player yet but he had a good year last year. With Grimes in the side it may help him which is a bonus but to stay safe I would go Simpson every day